Deathly Hallows Released : Post Comments (Don't post Spoilers)

[dreamcatcher]

^^^^ok ok chill dudes....nuthin to gt pissed off...now since all the fanboys and calvins are after me i hav to admit that sumthin went wrong..neways we were talking of alternatives to harry rite..here are a few..check them out..

Fiction

1.Samit Basu triology (Simoquin and Manticore..third yet to be released)
2.Inheritence triology(eragon.eldest...third to be released)
3.The bartemious triology

after harry potter the few most sought after books in recent times....

 

[aryayush]

@arya: Say it isn't so mate!! He loves her like a sister!!

Like Hell he does!

Hermione does not deserve to be stuck with Ron.

 

[kumarmohit]

Inheritence triology is rather cool man.

 

[xbonez]

^^yes i agree, inheritance trilogy is quite gud. the third book, rumored to be called empire, should be out this year. anyways, it isn't better than hp though

i hope they never make the movie for the seventh book. i don't want to see that a&& Rupert Grint kissing emma watson

 

[dreamcatcher]

ya man hp rocks all the way..but the inheritence triology could have been better..paulini culdnt really gel the things he had in mind in a proper way..shove the reins of this to jk u will have eragon kissing evy elf in the forest and saphira leaving eragon in search of mates...

by the way did hermione kiss ron in the book..i cant seem to recall...

@arya..hermione and ron make a good pair...cummon....just bcos sum idiot chose emma to represent hermione, she isnt such of beauty queen..is she..rowling cleared it out in the frst book but the producers dint seem to agree

by the way the bloomsbury cover is horribly wrong this time...ron with blonde hair...strange...they should be sued..LOL...

 

[aryayush]

by the way did hermione kiss ron in the book..i cant seem to recall...

Yes, unfortunately she did when he suddenly got all noble about saving the house elves in the kitchen during the war at Hogwarts. Bleagh!!

 

[Quiz_Master]

^^ Yeah. She kissed. And that was a long kiss then, Harry-Cho kiss or Harry-Ginny kiss...

Anyone heard that Naomi Watts will be Narcissa Malfoy in 6th movie?

I completed the 7th book twice now... Battle of Hogwarts is a very good chapter in my opinion. King-Cross was OKish, Epilogue...>Worst.

 

[fun2sh]

yeah. great book. wished she hadnt killed FRED and she could hav told nope abt the other too. but THATS JO'S PLAN COZ SHE IS MAKIN ENCYCLOPEDIA IN WHICH SHE WILL GIVE THE DETAILS ABT OTHER SO SHE HAS NOT GIVEN THAT IN THIS BOOK. SHE IS REALLY CUNNING LIKE A FOX

 

[rajdeepsingh86]

@Faraaz
yeah, i have read After The End
nice one.

btw, i am aware of all these fanfic sites. and believe me, none can be better than psychic seprent trilogy.

i can mail them to anyone who is inetrested, just pm me.


and one more point, in Deathly Hallows, harry repairs his pheonix holly wand
by using the elder wand.
i cant digest this. sounds too childish.
when Ollivander clearly said that it cant be repaired,i dont think any wand, no matter how powerful, can repair it.

 

[fun2sh]

^^^
typo error above instead of "nope" i meant "more" but i cant edit it usin opera mini

 

[rajdeepsingh86]

one more point.

when harry is going to present himself in front of voldemort, he thinks of the snitch. "i open at the close"
says, "im about to die" and the snitch opens.
another stupid thing.
how could have Dumledore foreseen that harry would think of the snitch when he will be so near to his deathbed and then he'll open it and get the resurrection stone?

 

[fun2sh]

wat i was goin to say
yeah remembered it.
rowlin had told in some interview that harry is not a HORCRUX but she made him one
and there are lot of undigestable things in this book
previously her plot and thinkin was based on good logical thinkin was well under a defined formed of rules. it was not like anything can be done usin magic. but in final book she has forgotten all this. now it seems that magic can do anything.

 

[rajdeepsingh86]

+1 to the above post

 

[xbonez]

talk about undigetable things. how the hell does neville pull out gryffindor's sword from the sorting hat?? wasn't it supposed to be with griphook. he'd taken it at gringotts. if the sorting hat can still present it, why didn't harry just pull out ravenclaw's diadem from the hat??

 

[goobimama]

Can anyone find me the fifth book of harry potter, the order of the phoenix (Fan fiction) which has this character Alania Dumbledore. Alania is Albus' grand daughter or something and she along with harry are two individuals who are "the order of the phoenix". It was damn good. Much much much better than the crap that came out later (written by JK rowling).

If anyone has it, I would really like to get my hands on it...ebook that is.

NOTE: IN CASE someone thinks this is another one of my SPAM POSTS, then its not. I'M ACTUALLY SERIOUS.

 

[rajdeepsingh86]

@Xbonez
i dont remember where,but once
dumbledore says that the sword of gryffindor can present itself to anyone which it seems worthy of the sword.

Neville pulled it out the same way Harry had pulled it in second year.
at that time, the sword was in Dumbledore's office. yet Harry pulled it out of the sorting hat.
so, i think that part is believable

diadem cant be pulled out, because its not the wizard who chooses to pull out things.


its the sorting hat that does the trick.


So, only a gryffindore can pull out the sword. and i guess the same applies to diadem.

 

[alsiladka]

I read some of the posts above, i would like to randomly like to reply to some of your comments before posting my comments on the book.

Hermione does not deserve to be around with Ron -
Well guys, he is not as dumb as he looks. He is a great chess player and played one of the greatest chess games in decades. He has loads of things in him, but they just need something to bring them out. Quiditch, and so many other instances.

Nevile taking out the sword from the sorting hat -
A student showing courage and bravery against one of the greatest wizards of modern times. Also, when no one dared come forward. I feel it was more an act of bravery than Harry's in COF.

About Deathly Hallows -

* The first half sucked, it sucked big time. Was really dissapointed with the first half.
* Second half salvaged the book, liked most of it, but not the way Voldy ended.

* When all the 7 books have been about "there are things worse than death", and dumbledore always maintained it, i felt the better ending would have been something other than the killing curse. it should have been something "worse than death".

* 7 books later, snape is my favorite character now.

* What would Voldy's boggart turn into, and does he feel anything when dementors are around him?

* Where ere the House Elves of Hogwarts kitchen?

* Who was the one who did magic late in his/her life that rowling had promised.

 

[Quiz_Master]

As I allready said,,,, lost of questions are unanswered in series...

But I like the concept of Deathly Hallows though...
Deatly Hallows Vs. Horcrux
Good Vs. Evil

But this book is least believable of all. JKR played with facts very badly.. sometimes magic happened without no reason...
And what was the role of non-verbal spells???

 

[rajdeepsingh86]

concept of deathly hallows sucks!

how is it possible that we have never read about it in the rest of the 6 six books and then suddenly, in seventh book, they make an appearance??

idiotic stuff!

 

[faraaz]

Well, I cannot deny that the book was rushed a bit, and JKR may have overstretched herself building up the clmiax and not been able to deliver.

But here's the thing:

* As far as Deathly Hallows go, Harry doesn't hear about it because he isn't given information by Dumbledore. And apart from Dumbledore, people don't really know too much about it, do they?? Either they are nutters who no one takes seriously (Xeno Lovegood) or they never heard of it (Ollivander...him not knowing gives credence to this theory). So its kinda believable that they never heard of it. Not saying its absolute gold as far as the plot goes...but believable, if you don't worry about it too much.

* And someone mentioned non-verbal spells. See, its a LOT cooler when you have say...Dumbledore vs. Voldemort in an all-out one on one duel using non-verbal spells. But when you are in Harry's perspective, using non-verbal spells makes no sense because you are in his head anyway, PLUS its a lot more dramatic to have that "Expelliarmus" every now and then. Besides, everyone except the heroes was using non-verbal spells, in case you didn't notice.