Nokia Mobile Replacement [5630 XM]

[kartikkapo]

hello guys, I had Nokia 5630 handset which stopped working and now the Nokia Care is replacing it with a brand new 5800. Should i go with 5800 or should i go with E71 if i don't get E72. can i ask them for a much more better model? My primary requirement is Wifi.
Any suggestions and comments would be of great help.

 

[desiibond]

5800XM: if you want a multimedia device
E71/E72: if you want a business class phone with office doc editing, emails etc.

see if you can get X6 instead

 

[coderunknown]

replacing? very kind of nokia this time.

well by pouring in 1k extra, nokia care guys may give the X6. try once.

 

[Gollum]

I've never herd of 5630.

 

[desiibond]

I've never herd of 5630.

Nokia 5630 XpressMusic - Full phone specifications

 

[aby geek]

yup i too told him to get x6
but he says the nokia care guy was saying x6 is also having problems.

he bought 5630 for 12.5k ,sadly there aint any at that price point exactly.
5800 appears to be the only choice.

x6 for 1k more are you sure sam? i think hell have to shell out 3k.

by the way what pricepoint does the new 5233 comes?

 

[coderunknown]

i not sure but he may get the 8Gb version. or it sells out for 15k+? anyway X6 better than 5800XM.

5233 should sell now for around 6k (6.3k in most online portals).

 

[kartikkapo]

X6 doesn't have a card slot, wont pinch me much though. i might get the 8gb one. anyone having used it without any glitches?
How about E72 over E71, if i manage to persuade them for 1-2k extra? (no comparison with x6 though)

 

[Zangetsu]

@kartikkapo: hey does nokia care replaces all nokia old non working models.....???

 

[NainO]

Prefer X6 over 5800XM and E72 over E71...
If you want a multimedia phones go for X6 or if you want a qwerty keypad go for E72...

X6 over 5800XM -
1. Capacitive touch
2. 5MP camera
3. IMO better look
4. (Slightly) better UI

E72 over E71 -
1. 5MP camera
2. better built quality
3. HSDPA 10.2Mbps(vs 3.6Mbps)
4. Optical trackpad

 

[kartikkapo]

@kartikkapo: hey does nokia care replaces all nokia old non working models.....???

no dude not all, only the ones in warranty or extended warranty.

Prefer X6 over 5800XM and E72 over E71...
If you want a multimedia phones go for X6 or if you want a qwerty keypad go for E72...

X6 over 5800XM -
1. Capacitive touch
2. 5MP camera
3. IMO better look
4. (Slightly) better UI

E72 over E71 -
1. 5MP camera
2. better built quality
3. HSDPA 10.2Mbps(vs 3.6Mbps)
4. Optical trackpad

hey nainO, this is a real nyc comparison.. awesome.

thank you guys for the quick response and suggestions.. \m/ have placed my request for X6.. hope to get it in a week.. fingers crossed..