Movies Discussion Thread V1: Ratings and Opinions

eggman

I have Yolks not Brains!
Did you know that "The Departed" was a copy of a Korean movie? Guess what? It was a hit!

Your argument is flawed because makers of Departed >>>>>>bought<<<<< the rights of Infernal Affairs(and it is NOT a Korean film , for God's sake) before remaking The Departed!!!So it's a REMAKE not Rip-Off. Rip-off is something that partner is of Hitch!!! Or ZINDA is of OLDBOY!!!
I do not know how to say it more clearly but remakes is not a bad thing!!!Rip offs are!!!
 

iMav

The Devil's Advocate
When will you understand that the discussion IS NOT on who bought the rights and legally made the movie! No one is discussing rights & lefts! For the nth time let the producers battle the rights issue! Man what am I to do to get this across to you! Damn man!

The discussion is about Bollywood movies being bad because they put songs & make longer versions of Hollywood movies!


Besides if you want to argue on this stupid point which isn't even a consideration in the discussion then let me throw this - Ghajini is not a rip-off of Memento, it's a remake of a South movie, where were you when the South guy made the movie? I didn't see you drawing distinctions between remakes & rip-offs.

Besides,according to the way your talking, its abso-fcking-lutely fine if you watch a DVD rip but when a director makes a movie without buying rights he is wrong? Man, I sure don't want you to be a jury member if God forbid I land up in court.

Dude, please go through the discussion again to understand what 1 is talking about, then blabber.

And Korean or whatever, it was a remake of an Asian film I guess, 'coz IA had all Asian actors as far as i remember.
 
Last edited:

RCuber

The Mighty Unkel!!!
Staff member
Does the average movie goer care a bit if the movie is a remake or a rip off!! .. they just go to the movie just to enjoy.
 

eggman

I have Yolks not Brains!

The discussion is about Bollywood movies being bad because they put songs & make longer versions of Hollywood movies!
Is it???
Then I am outta discussion!!! Bad Movie/Good Movie is all subjective:) . I do like Chachi 420 more Than Mrs. Doubtfire!!! :D
 

rhitwick

Democracy is a myth
OffTopic//
Err is there any porn movie that brings tears to your eyes and titillates you with emotions ?
I've seen a few with stories but none of them were tear-jerkers...
I don't think porn maker would love to see their audience crying rather "doing" after (during) watching their movies:rolleyes:*s269.photobucket.com/albums/jj44/visio159/Unismilies/5.png
 

Faun

Wahahaha~!
Staff member
Das Boot (1981) and beware its almost 4 hours long!!!
One of the best movie, I was literally in a submarine (U-boat) throughout the movie. It felt so real, zomg I never felt when 4 hours ended. That radar beep was so scary...teet....teeet....teeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeet:D
And this is based on real story makes it even more engaging.
Ending was done well too.
 

gopi_vbboy

Cyborg Agent
Breaking News:-
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
MNS Supporters Thrash Theatres screening Ghajni Movie.They felt like in the introduction song asin spelled Mumbai as Bombay.even Amir spelled the same
:(
MNS Demands an Unforgetful appology from Ghajini scipt makers for huting Their Sentiments:(

..........
..
{continue..After a breaker}:confused:
.
.

....
.
..

.Aap dekthey rahiye :p

..
.
.
.
..
..
.
.
.
.
.
.
.

.
.India TV:D:D:D:D:D:D:D
 

rhitwick

Democracy is a myth
Les Diaboliques(1955) 9/10

Man,...its an awesome movie.
This is how a mystery should be handled.

Recommended to everyone. Go 4 it.

P.S. I guess 9 on 10 is less for it, take 9.5*s269.photobucket.com/albums/jj44/visio159/Unismilies/31.png
 
Last edited:

gaurav_indian

CG Artist
Thank you for the enlightenment! We were sleeping till you came along. ;)

So how does buying rights mean that Hollywood's movies are better or worse? Talk about the movie and not the legal aspects of it. What's wrong legally is wrong, let the producers bother about it. But, saying that Bollywood rips off and therefore it sucks is plain immaturity on one's part. Indian movies (Bollywood) have always had longer story, song & dance. That's Bollywod/Indian movie "culture" just because they add songs into a movie that was made in Hollywood doesn't mean that the movie is crap or whatever. Bollywood movies are made for an audience that likes the song & dance in Ghajini.

Stop comparing Hollywood & Bollywood everytime a copy is released.

@jack, Ghajini is a remake of a South movie, I did not see a single post by anyone condemning it the way it is being done now. Why is that? And as far as masterpieces go, no director plans to fcuk a movie. When you're making a movie you make to sell & be appreciated for it. Songs are an integral part of our movie culture, we, the ones who call ourselves great critics & start calling movies as "masterpieces" need to understand that.

Every time an alleged copy is released we start comparing 7 giving our verdict. Never will we consider it as a single entity give our views, that ok this was good or that was bad. It's always, they have music sh!theads. How can you have songs in a movie?

Comparing is fair, comparisons should be made but bashing a movie because it did not "buy" the rights or it added songs is stupid.

The sensibilities of an Indian audience are way different than those in the West, YOU need to understand that. Ghajini has beautiful songs! I too find songs ruin the fun of the movie, but that's our "movie culture"


+1 Agreed with every single word.

And there is a difference b/w a theme and story.;)

Wow iMav, you really opened my eyes!

[*goes off to the nearest store to buy 100000s of Bollywood CDs and DVDs bcoz iMav uncle is paid to advertise Bollywood.]

BTW guys, do watch Momento. Its a great movie but sadly its ruined by our great 'BOLLYWOOD'! Yay!

Wtf do you mean by it was ruined by Bollywood?I am pissed off by guys like you living in india and praising all western things.:rolleyes:
 
Last edited:

Ethan_Hunt

Aspiring Novelist
Mirrors - 8/10. Finally a good horror movie in recent times. Very entertaining but the end was a bit loose. A sequel might be expected from the end. Excellent acting by Kiefer Sutherland & a must watch movie.
 

The_Devil_Himself

die blizzard die! D3?
The Pianist-6-7\10.

slumdog millionaire-5\10.Nowhere near 'city of god',stupid people with still stupider comparisons.City of god is a total masterpiece a 10\10.

transporter 3 -4\10,you could atleast cast a half-decent actress.

Forrest Gump -9\10.there are two kind of people in the world,the ones who have watched forrest gump and the rest who haven't........absolute must watch.
 

rhitwick

Democracy is a myth
Forrest Gump -9\10.there are two kind of people in the world,the ones who have watched forrest gump and the rest who haven't........absolute must watch.
Tom Hanks FTW....*s269.photobucket.com/albums/jj44/visio159/Unismilies/28large.png

Max Payne, sorry should report in "Must not watch"...:evil:
 

Rockstar11

Technomancer
Breaking News:-
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
MNS Supporters Thrash Theatres screening Ghajni Movie.They felt like in the introduction song asin spelled Mumbai as Bombay.even Amir spelled the same
:(
MNS Demands an Unforgetful appology from Ghajini scipt makers for huting Their Sentiments:(

..........
..
{continue..After a breaker}:confused:
.
.

....
.
..

.Aap dekthey rahiye :p

..
.
.
.
..
..
.
.
.
.
.
.
.

.
.India TV:D:D:D:D:D:D:D

lol
 

Psychosocial

Violent serenity.
Mirrors - 8/10. Finally a good horror movie in recent times. Very entertaining but the end was a bit loose. A sequel might be expected from the end. Excellent acting by Kiefer Sutherland & a must watch movie.

Yes, I have mentioned this movie before a couple of pages. Its just amazing! BTW, the ending was good unlike the 'good ol' happy ending' :). Sequel is prolly coming out and I am waiting for it!

+1 Agreed with every single word.

And there is a difference b/w a theme and story.;)



Wtf do you mean by it was ruined by Bollywood?I am pissed off by guys like you living in india and praising all western things.:rolleyes:

I am not picking up a fight with you but I am not living but 'stuck' here. Bcoz I am still 14, mom and dad wont let me go out of this sh1thole(THIS IS MY SOLE OPINION. PLEASE DONT START JUMPING MY A$$ IN SUPPORT OF INDIA) till 16 or so :(. Damn!

Ok now, OT :- gonna watch Passengers and Airplane today :).
 
Last edited:
Top Bottom