My friend has already watched both Toradora and Another.
My friend wants to watch maid-sama and so do I. Being a dull show does not come into the picture. Probably gonna replace stein's gate though (for lack of good sources) but
not sure what Shu.ge is...
Not doing visual novels in an anime marathon with a friend either
Not sure if I will use Genocyber though, because my friend isn't a fan of older series. Depends on if he likes the art style.
I'm speaking from what I read in the rule book.
EDIT: As of now, the Anime marathon may or may not happen- reason being midterms only a few days after thanksgiving.