Windows vs Linux: Power to the user

[Desmond]

How long have you been using Linux?
4 years
How long have you been using Windows?
12 years
Which OS did you begin using first?
Windows 3.1

Objectives

1. When you installed Linux/Windows, which one did you find easier to install?
Windows (took some time to get a hang of linux installation)
2. Which OS provided the best default programs post installation?
Linux (Depends on distro, but never usually disappointed)
3. Which of the OS's provided the best default web browser based on 1.functionality, 2.security, and 3.user-friendliness?
This would obviously be FireFox on Linux
4. Which OS did you find better to customize based on how easy it was to customize, the amount of visual and audible appeal, and the variety of customization available for the OS.
Windows (any version), though I think Linux is equally easy.
5. Which OS did you find it easier to add new programs based on how easy it was to find the software, how easy it was to install.
WINDOWS, installing in Linux is a pain in the ***, took me a week to figure out how to install from Tarballs, also, did'nt have net then to install from apt
6. Which OS provided a better networking experience in terms of security, setting up a LAN (wired and wireless), printer (network or direct) and functionality.
Ease of setting up : Windows. Never tried networking in Linux
7. Which OS is a better base for productivity, whether it be programming,
writing, graphical design, etc. ( It can be a combination of these if you do more than one. Feel free to add your own.)
Only done all of these properly in Windows. Mostly only done Java/C programming in Linux (Ubuntu mainly)
8. Which OS provided better file and folder management based on copying
and moving files, finding your files, adding and deleting files.
Linux is much better in this area
9. Which OS was easier to maintain based on scanning/removing viruses and malware, defragmenting and cleaning up disk space, and backing up your information.
Only Windows has problems with malware, never had any malware problem with Linux
10. Which OS do you find easier to troubleshoot based on man/info/help pages, working out issues on your own, and online help like forums and online
documentation.
Both
11. Which OS provided the most stability and performance based on cpu usage, peripheral hardware compatibility (IE: mouse, tablet, webcam), software and OS freezing, crashing, locking-up, and hardware compatibility.
Windows most stable (mainly due to availability of drivers), Linux hardly detects my modem, let alone install it
12. Anything additional worth a mention as far as this comparison between Linux and Windows goes?
Linux is better when it comes to security and stability, providing for a robust development and enterprise platform. However, it is somewhat weaker when it comes to user-friendliness. Windows is commonplace, but falls weak for security and Virus/malware problems, requiring constant maintainence.

 

[Liverpool_fan]

5. Which OS did you find it easier to add new programs based on how easy it was to find the software, how easy it was to install.
WINDOWS, installing in Linux is a pain in the ***, took me a week to figure out how to install from Tarballs, also, did'nt have net then to install from apt

You don't need to use tarballs.
If you want to install on an offline PC - Keryx Project|Updates for offline Linux users
Just a tip

 

[sakumar79]

How long have you been using Linux?
On and off since 1997

How long have you been using Windows?
From the days of Windows3.1

Which OS did you begin using first?
DOS

Objectives (Please provide a short explanation for your experiences in each of the provided tasks):
1. When you installed Linux/Windows, which one did you find easier to install?
Both were relatively easy... I have installed Linux both with text-based UI and Graphical interface... Overall, Windows is easier... Two minuses for Windows are 1. that it requires some inputs in the middle of installation rather than keeping it to the start or the end, and 2. there are no ways to tweak the installation from the original installation disc - options like nLite not considered...Linux on the other hand gets most of the input at the initial stage and then starts installation... And with advanced options, I can even setup the packages to install and the ones to avoid...
But ease of use wise, Windows installation experience is still better

2. Which OS provided the best default programs post installation?
Some with Windows (basic notepad, calculator, wmp, Paint etc), some with linux (Openoffice, multiple desktops, etc)...

3. Which of the OS's provided the best default web browser based on 1.functionality, 2.security, and 3.user-friendliness?
For me, Opera is the browser of choice... Second is Chrome... Dont like firefox very much, and use IE to browse the few IE-specific sites... So, default browser wise, neither actually (unless you consider a custom Linux build with opera pre-installed and set as default; but of course that would be equivalent to a nLite customised Windows installation with opera installed by default... So, effectively, NEITHER... To me, the main reason I hate firefox is that I need to have a handful of add-ons for doing many of the things I need to do... I work with many computers and managing addons for each computer is a headache... I bear with IE because it gets the job done even if it is not as efficient as Opera...

4. Which OS did you find better to customize based on how easy it was to customize, the amount of visual and audible appeal, and the variety of customization available for the OS.
Windows without a doubt...

5. Which OS did you find it easier to add new programs based on how easy it was to find the software, how easy it was to install.
Both are relatively easy... In linux, if the program is within the distros repository, then it is easy, but if not, programs are basically the same - search and find, download and install...

6. Which OS provided a better networking experience in terms of security, setting up a LAN (wired and wireless), printer (network or direct) and functionality.
Windows... While Windows implementations leads to some minor problems once in a while, it is easier to setup and maintain for LAN, printer, etc...

7. Which OS is a better base for productivity, whether it be programming,
writing, graphical design, etc. ( It can be a combination of these if you do more than one. Feel free to add your own.)
Windows... For programming ease, there is nothing like Visual Studio Express Edition... Free to use and very easy to program... For writing, I use OpenOffice, so it doesnt matter whether Windows or Linux is the platform... For many others, I am dependant on Windows as there are no Linux alternative...

8. Which OS provided better file and folder management based on copying
and moving files, finding your files, adding and deleting files.
Both are relatively equal...

9. Which OS was easier to maintain based on scanning/removing viruses and malware, defragmenting and cleaning up disk space, and backing up your information.
For clearing viruses and defragmentation Linux is better.
Never had to clear disk space as I regularly remove old data, so cannot commend...
Backup tools available with third party vendors for Windows are better... Havent used default tools of Linux or Windows.

10. Which OS do you find easier to troubleshoot based on man/info/help pages, working out issues on your own, and online help like forums and online
documentation.
Windows... Most of the problems solved by Googling, but with Linux, the percentage of problems solved by googling and rtfm is less...

11. Which OS provided the most stability and performance based on cpu usage, peripheral hardware compatibility (IE: mouse, tablet, webcam), software and OS freezing, crashing, locking-up, and hardware compatibility.
windows - OS freezing out of the box is rare in both, hardware compatibility with built-in drivers is equal but many hardware are provided with windows drivers only... For cpu usage, havent checked strenuously... Out of box cpu usage in both windows and Linux is similar for same hardware and when similar versions are used (older OS with older hardware, etc)...

12. Anything additional worth a mention as far as this comparison between Linux and Windows goes?
I installed Linux Mint for my uncle who frequently had virus problems in his XP system... He used it for a month but could not use the webcam due to lack of drivers (local make)... So, for skype, he used windows... At next system crash, he did not reinstall Linux - the local service engineer did not have necessary skills for reinstalling/recovering Linux... The end user is finding Linux more and more user-friendly, but corporations providing only Windows drivers is still a major cause of concern for Linux adoption at a much larger scale...

Additionally, many field specialised domains have Windows-only software which makes people in such fields have no option but to stay with Windows...

Finally, I feel that the "Out Of The Box experience" is overhyped... Whether I use Windows or Linux, I install the software I want and remove the ones I dont... Only the end product experience matters... For me, Windows still beats Linux... But Linux is catching... It still needs to address three main focus issues - better driver compatibility, gaming and better commercial software for all fields...

Arun

 

[ico]

But Linux is catching... It still needs to address three main focus issues - better driver compatibility, gaming and better commercial software for all fields...

I appreciate your experience which you have shared in your post. But these I feel are more in the hands of developers.

For example, I bought a Canon scanner and Canon provides ZERO support for Linux. Surely not Linux's fault. Games, again it is in the hands of developers. Although we are optimistic about Steam for Linux. With OpenGL rendered Valve games already available for Mac OS X, I think they aren't far away from Linux.

 

[6x6]

How long have you been using Linux?
- 4 years

How long have you been using Windows?
- 10 years

Which OS did you begin using first?
- windows 98

1. When you installed Linux/Windows, which one did you find easier to install?
- both are more or less same.

2. Which OS provided the best default programs post installation?
-Linux

3. Which of the OS's provided the best default web browser based on 1.functionality - IE6 is crap, IE8 is OK
2.security - I feel Linux is better
3.user-friendliness - cant say, both are more or less same.


4. Which OS did you find better to customize based on how easy it was to customize, the amount of visual and audible appeal, and the variety of customization available for the OS.
- both are more or less same.

5. Which OS did you find it easier to add new programs based on how easy it was to find the software, how easy it was to install.
- Linux

6. Which OS provided a better networking experience in terms of security, setting up a LAN (wired and wireless), printer (network or direct) and functionality.
- both are more or less same. in Linux we dont need driver cds

7. Which OS is a better base for productivity, whether it be programming,
writing, graphical design, etc. ( It can be a combination of these if you do more than one. Feel free to add your own.)
- cant say

8. Which OS provided better file and folder management based on copying
and moving files, finding your files, adding and deleting files.
- both are more or less same.

9. Which OS was easier to maintain based on scanning/removing viruses and malware, defragmenting and cleaning up disk space, and backing up your information.
- Linux

10. Which OS do you find easier to troubleshoot based on man/info/help pages, working out issues on your own, and online help like forums and online documentation.
- Linux

11. Which OS provided the most stability and performance based on cpu usage, peripheral hardware compatibility (IE: mouse, tablet, webcam), software and OS freezing, crashing, locking-up, and hardware compatibility.
- Linux

12. Anything additional worth a mention as far as this comparison between Linux and Windows goes?
- some websites dont work in Linux,
- some cds (specially educational cds given with children books having exe files) dont work in Linux
- most of the games dont work in Linux
- special updating software like - nokia / SE mobile software updater does not work in Linux

 

[ico]

- some websites dont work in Linux,

Web devs are to be blamed.

- some cds (specially educational cds given with children books having exe files) dont work in Linux

Can't comment.

- most of the games dont work in Linux

Linux games work on Linux.

- special updating software like - nokia / SE mobile software updater does not work in Linux

Hardware vendors are to be blamed for not giving their Linux users such options.

 

[papul1993]

How long have you been using Linux?
-->3 years

How long have you been using Windows?
--> 8years

Which OS did you begin using first?
--> Windows 98

1. When you installed Linux/Windows, which one did you find easier to install?
--> Linux distros like ubuntu, linux mint are easier to install than Windows OS but the same can't be said about distros like Archlinux , Gentoo etc.

2. Which OS provided the best default programs post installation?
--> Linux Mint.

3. Which of the OS's provided the best default web browser based on 1.functionality, 2.security, and 3.user-friendliness?
-->Almost all Linux distros provide firefox as the default web browser.

4. Which OS did you find better to customize based on how easy it was to customize, the amount of visual and audible appeal, and the variety of customization available for the OS.
--> Linux Mint

5. Which OS did you find it easier to add new programs based on how easy it was to find the software, how easy it was to install.
--> Linux. New and updated software are avalable in the repos that are just a command away from being installed on your system.

6. Which OS provided a better networking experience in terms of security, setting up a LAN (wired and wireless), printer (network or direct) and functionality.
--> I haven't yet tried connect a network printer and setting up a wireless network so in my opinion both Windows and Linux are almost same in this regard. But in Linux distros like ubuntu or linux mint you are generally provided with the network manager applet which make configuring networks a breeze.

7. Which OS is a better base for productivity, whether it be programming,
writing, graphical design, etc. ( It can be a combination of these if you do more than one. Feel free to add your own.)
--> Linux is better suited for programming. But in case of work like photo editing, video/audio editing, 3d animation etc Windows is better suited because top of the line softwares for these kind of jobs are generally made for Windows OS.

8. Which OS provided better file and folder management based on copying
and moving files, finding your files, adding and deleting files.
--> IMO both Windows and linux are equal in this case

9. Which OS was easier to maintain based on scanning/removing viruses and malware, defragmenting and cleaning up disk space, and backing up your information.
--> Linux!! It doesn't get those stupid windows viruses.

10. Which OS do you find easier to troubleshoot based on man/info/help pages, working out issues on your own, and online help like forums and online
documentation.
--> Linux. It has a good community of people that help on forums, IRC channels etc.

11. Which OS provided the most stability and performance based on cpu usage, peripheral hardware compatibility (IE: mouse, tablet, webcam), software and OS freezing, crashing, locking-up, and hardware compatibility.
--> Windows has better hardware compatibly at this moment but I am sure this will change soon.

12. Anything additional worth a mention as far as this comparison between Linux and Windows goes?
--> Gaming. Windows definately wins in this case.

 

[sakumar79]

@ico, in many Windows vs Linux comparisons, I am noticing this tendency among Linux supporters... When someone says that Linux needs to catch up on hardware support, Linux fans mention that it is not Linux's fault but hardware manufacturers fault for not providing it... But then, they go out to point that many tools like OpenOffice, etc are pre-bundled with Linux but not with Windows as an advantage... If Windows were to bundle software, there would be lot of Anti Trust actions (remember the hoopla when Windows Vista/7 started a different security mechanism? and remember IE and WMP cases in Europe?)... This is "not our problem" the Linux supporters say... If we look at it impartially, if it is not their problem and the point is to be considered for comparing Lin and Win, then it is not the Windows users problem that hardware vendors do not give Linux drivers and that point should be considered also...

IMHO, if we are comparing Linux vs Windows, both points HAVE to be considered because we are to look at it impartially from the end user point of view where the end user will be affected by these points which may become an issue to him... And here, it is to be noted that the problem in Windows is more easily solved (getting third party software) than some of the Linux problems (hardware support)... But should be noted that Windows problems may be universal (in all cases) whereas Linux problems are case-specific (incompatibility with some hardware)

Arun

 

[SunnyChahal]

How long have you been using Linux?

On and off since 2007. So, roughly 3 years.

How long have you been using Windows?

9 years.

Which OS did you begin using first?

Microsoft Windows 98.

1. When you installed Linux/Windows, which one did you find easier to install?

Windows. Easy partitioning. The entire process of installing Linux is pretty simple except partitioning, for some.

2. Which OS provided the best default programs post installation?

Linux. No two ways about that. A chat application, web browser, image editing software and anything else you would want for an OS to have right out of the box.

3. Which of the OS's provided the best default web browser based on 1.functionality, 2.security, and 3.user-friendliness?

Linux (Ubuntu). Mozilla firefox is fully functional, very secure and user-friendly.

4. Which OS did you find better to customize based on how easy it was to customize, the amount of visual and audible appeal, and the variety of customization available for the OS.

Linux is easier to customize and there are a lot of themes out there but out of the box, Windows 7 looks much better and more polished. So, for customization it is Linux but for visual appeal it's Windows.

5. Which OS did you find it easier to add new programs based on how easy it was to find the software, how easy it was to install.

I haven't used many other distros except Ubuntu. Synaptic Manager is very easy to use and installing new apps doesn't take much effort. And 'apt-get' is always there for the more geeky users. But installing the apps which are not available in the Synaptic Manager is a chore. Compiling and all isn't my cup of tea. Installing thrid party apps for Windows seems easier. I would say that for me, both operating systems tie in this department.

6. Which OS provided a better networking experience in terms of security, setting up a LAN (wired and wireless), printer (network or direct) and functionality.

Security - Linux

Setup(Wireless) - Windows. What can I say, my Wi-Fi dongle doesn't work with Linux.

Printer - Windows.

Functionality - Windows.

7. Which OS is a better base for productivity, whether it be programming,
writing, graphical design, etc. ( It can be a combination of these if you do more than one. Feel free to add your own.)

Not much into programming or designing, so I wouldn't say anything here.

8. Which OS provided better file and folder management based on copying
and moving files, finding your files, adding and deleting files.

I am used to the way Windows handles files. I'll go with Windows here. Linux is pretty good too.

9. Which OS was easier to maintain based on scanning/removing viruses and malware, defragmenting and cleaning up disk space, and backing up your information.

Linux. Doesn't need an anti-virus, defragmenting or any other of that stuff. Totally robust when it comes to security.

10. Which OS do you find easier to troubleshoot based on man/info/help pages, working out issues on your own, and online help like forums and online
documentation.

Both.

11. Which OS provided the most stability and performance based on cpu usage, peripheral hardware compatibility (IE: mouse, tablet, webcam), software and OS freezing, crashing, locking-up, and hardware compatibility.

Windows 7 for me.

12. Anything additional worth a mention as far as this comparison between Linux and Windows goes?

Well, both operating systems are great but as I'm a gamer, Windows is an indispensible part of my life. I dual boot Windows and Linux and I like both of them. I don't really divide tasks between the two operating systems. Sometimes I go weeks without using Windows, the other times Linux is never booted for months. Just depends on the mood.

 

[papul1993]

Linux is easier to customize and there are a lot of themes out there but out of the box, Windows 7 looks much better and more polished. So, for customization it is Linux but for visual appeal it's Windows.

tell me, have you used KDE? It very much windows like. Polished. And many of its features were copied and used in Windows 7, like windows maximizing when dragged to the top of the screen etc.

 

[SunnyChahal]

No, last time I used KDE was in early 2009. Don't remember much. I just posted my opinions. I'm not imposing them on anyone.

 

[vamsi_krishna]

How long have you been using Linux?

2007 (Fedora)

How long have you been using Windows?

In school.It was in 2001. So, 9 Years.

Which OS did you begin using first?

Windows 98


Objectives (Please provide a short explanation for your experiences in each of the provided tasks):

1. When you installed Linux/Windows, which one did you find easier to install?

Except the partitioning part, Linux was pretty easy. And, quick as well.

2. Which OS provided the best default programs post installation?

Linux distros all the way. But There is media player... but only OGG support. Most of the collection was in MP3. And same is with videos.

3. Which of the OS's provided the best default web browser based on 1.functionality, 2.security, and 3.user-friendliness?

Linux. But before firefox release(2004), I don't know how better other browsers was than IE5,6

4. Which OS did you find better to customize based on how easy it was to customize, the amount of visual and audible appeal, and the variety of customization available for the OS.

If I was posting this a day before. i would have said Windows. But today, I realized how beautiful Linux(ubuntu) will look after 1 hour time investment.

Ubutnu.

5. Which OS did you find it easier to add new programs based on how easy it was to find the software, how easy it was to install.

Windows. It is not a easy task to install programs in Linux atleast for newbies in this area. I'm still scratching my head to figure out sudo commands. Where as installation in windows environment was pretty easy.

6. Which OS provided a better networking experience in terms of security, setting up a LAN (wired and wireless), printer (network or direct) and
functionality.

I'm using ubuntu now. And, it is a bit flexible than windows LAN setup. With features like "connect automatically", etc.

7. Which OS is a better base for productivity, whether it be programming,
writing, graphical design, etc. ( It can be a combination of these if you do more than one. Feel free to add your own.)

I will go with Windows in this department. It might be because i was taught in windows environment and there are wide variety of tools available for gfx design, etc. In windows environment.


8. Which OS provided better file and folder management based on copying
and moving files, finding your files, adding and deleting files.

I will say I find Windows much more organized. It might be just me. But, searching files, finding files in a folder was easy for me in windows. It might be because I spent such a long time in there.

9. Which OS was easier to maintain based on scanning/removing viruses and malware, defragmenting and cleaning up disk space, and backing up your information.

I don't know if I ever need a AV suite when I'm in linux. And, Internet Security suits to warn about malicious websites, are present in windows, which will guarantee on line security, but linux has no comprehensive IS suits.. So, its a tough call. If i have to make a choice, i will go with Linux.

10. Which OS do you find easier to troubleshoot based on man/info/help pages, working out issues on your own, and online help like forums and online
documentation.

Windows. Just because I know pretty much about it. But Linux is a oblivion for me. So, i have to try myself upside down to solve a problem. And as most of the troubleshooting is command line based in linux, it is a bit hard. Where as in windows, it isn't that much.

11. Which OS provided the most stability and performance based on cpu usage, peripheral hardware compatibility (IE: mouse, tablet, webcam), software and OS freezing, crashing, locking-up, and hardware compatibility.

Linux. Every time I un installed my linux operating system, it was just because..reasons like "enough, we install some other time", "OMG! I ran out of space to install games", etc. But where as when i remove windows..it's because of crashes, issues with softwares, drivers, BSOD, slow downs, clutter, etc.

12. Anything additional worth a mention as far as this comparison between Linux and Windows goes?[/QUOTE]

Both have their own advantages and dis advantages. At the end of the day, what one should ask oneself is. "what do I want" Is it gaming? Surfing? Graphics Design? Web design?, etc and should go with the OS which satisfies their needs. Windows is good for some reasons and bad for some, same is with Linux. And, some of them say people don't go with linux because they don't know about it.. I don't agree with this at all. It might be because of the games or the tools that aren't available to them in Linux. So, please make a note of this.

 

[mayur gaikwad]

How long have you been using Linux?
2 years

How long have you been using Windows?
10 years

Which OS did you begin using first?
DOS


Objectives (Please provide a short explanation for your experiences in each of the provided tasks):

1. When you installed Linux/Windows, which one did you find easier to install?

First I installed Windows 98 found it quite difficult for 1st time.I installed Ubuntu (my personal favorite) some 3 yrs ago when I was beginner to Linux.
Found the installer damn easy when you experiment on Windows installing.



2. Which OS provided the best default programs post installation?

Ubuntu 10.10 my all time favorite and its Ubuntu Software Center.

3. Which of the OS's provided the best default web browser based on 1.functionality, 2.security, and 3.user-friendliness?

functionality: Firefox trumps IE
security: I prefer Firefox for its adblocking features

user friendliness: Firefox is more user friendly

4. Which OS did you find better to customize based on how easy it was to customize, the amount of visual and audible appeal, and the variety of customization available for the OS.

Ease of customization: Ubuntu is better.

audio visual appeal: Windows 7 is very good but Ubuntu 10.10 also kicks butt.

customization available to the OS: Linux got it here.OPEN SOURCE!!! Ubuntu Tweak etc are damn good.

5. Which OS did you find it easier to add new programs based on how easy it was to find the software, how easy it was to install.

Windows got easy with double click.Ubuntu Software Center now available wins here with variety.

6. Which OS provided a better networking experience in terms of security, setting up a LAN (wired and wireless), printer (network or direct) and functionality.

Windows is pain in ass with security,Ubuntu makes it quite tough.

7. Which OS is a better base for productivity, whether it be programming,
writing, graphical design, etc. ( It can be a combination of these if you do more than one. Feel free to add your own.)

Windows is Emperor in this field.Programming,Gaming and Designing are damn easy with Windows.

8. Which OS provided better file and folder management based on copying and moving files, finding your files, adding and deleting files.

Ubuntu is quite handy in file management

9. Which OS was easier to maintain based on scanning/removing viruses and malware, defragmenting and cleaning up disk space, and backing up your information.

Ubuntu finally scores 10 on 10 ,no viruses(if present i m unaware),no ****ing defragmentation.

10. Which OS do you find easier to troubleshoot based on man/info/help pages, working out issues on your own, and online help like forums and online documentation.

Windows is quite easy to troubleshoot will Ubuntu requires deep knowledge of libraries.

11. Which OS provided the most stability and performance based on cpu usage, peripheral hardware compatibility (IE: mouse, tablet, webcam), software and OS freezing, crashing, locking-up, and hardware compatibility.

hardware compatibility out of the box: Windows got it but Ubuntu making Steady progress

stability of the OS itself : Linux is much much more stable & no blue screen till now

12. Anything additional worth a mention as far as this comparison between Linux and Windows goes?

Windows is used due to easiness and much more due to PIRACY .Only legitimate I have seen are bundled with laps.Awareness of Linux is much less even Government promotes Windows by MS-CIT.So when people will realize LINUX as safe,secure,handy and free OS they will surely adopt it as their default OS.

 

[anuvrat_parashar]

How long have you been using Linux?
Over an year now. I am the vice-president of linux club at my college

How long have you been using Windows?
1998-2005 - at school only
2005-2008 - windows xp at home


Which OS did you begin using first?
at school it was MS-DOS at first - then Win 98
properly at home - started with XP

Objectives (Please provide a short explanation for your experiences in each of the provided tasks):

1. When you installed Linux/Windows, which one did you find easier to install?
Both were equally simpler because. I think I tried to installed FreeBSD or Ubuntu for the first time in 2007. Installed successfully but didn't use it then

2. Which OS provided the best default programs post installation?
Mandriva 2009 was the first distro to stay on my laptop for long.. It came with pretty much everything I needed. Where as it took me whole day to confiture Windows when I reinstalled it.
All distributions of linux offer most of the softwares one needs.

3. Which of the OS's provided the best default web browser based on 1.functionality, 2.security, and 3.user-friendliness?
By the time I had access to Internet on my system I was already fond of firefox ... so I liked it when I found it to be the default on Linux.
But frankly I didn't every try to test the browser - I like firefox .. I use it

4. Which OS did you find better to customize based on how easy it was to customize, the amount of visual and audible appeal, and the variety of customization available for the OS.
Windows does offer customisation but one can customize to a very great extent on gnome and KDE

5. Which OS did you find it easier to add new programs based on how easy it was to find the software, how easy it was to install.
when I was a newbie to linux - everything about windows was easy-peasy
after becoming familiar with linux and getting it setup properly
finding - easy and free on Linux
installing - from repository on Linux - very easy
- from source code - slightly difficult

without Internet - very difficult for linux - removing dependencies is impossible
on windows without internet - one can find Softwares on Digit's DVDs too


6. Which OS provided a better networking experience in terms of security, setting up a LAN (wired and wireless), printer (network or direct) and functionality.
never tried that stuff on windows - found it to be simple on linux

7. Which OS is a better base for productivity, whether it be programming,
writing, graphical design, etc. ( It can be a combination of these if you do more than one. Feel free to add your own.)
I participate in programming competitions - and am interested in coding in C/C++
so it was only after I came to linux and found about gcc that I came to know that Turbo C++ was outdated and C++ was way more than what I knew.


8. Which OS provided better file and folder management based on copying
and moving files, finding your files, adding and deleting files.
I find both to be same

9. Which OS was easier to maintain based on scanning/removing viruses and malware, defragmenting and cleaning up disk space, and backing up your information.
Linux - frankly never installed any antivirus suite

10. Which OS do you find easier to troubleshoot based on man/info/help pages, working out issues on your own, and online help like forums and online
documentation.
didn't require such help for windows - by the time I used windows - I had no interenet.
On Linux - found it to be great to find so many people to help me

11. Which OS provided the most stability and performance based on cpu usage, peripheral hardware compatibility (IE: mouse, tablet, webcam), software and OS freezing, crashing, locking-up, and hardware compatibility.
Windows was stable - didn't require any configuring to make hardware work.
But once I got things working on my new laptop with linux - its never been ever looking back.

12. Anything additional worth a mention as far as this comparison between Linux and Windows goes?
Windows a good OS but I find Linux to be better. Its only because of having been taught (literally in schools) to use Windows that people find it difficult to use Linux. It was extremely difficult for me to get linux up and running on my new Laptop ( no drivers for new hardware). Once that was solved - I seldom boot into my Win7 partition.
Applications that I use often and find better in comparison

• GCC - programming
• firefox - browsing
• emacs - text editing
• vlc - music and video
• scribus - document editing

 

[cyberjar09]

Windows vs Linux: Discussion from feedback thread

How long have you been using Linux?

Which OS did you begin using first?
Windows. Obvious, isn’t it?

Which version of Windows did you begin using?

the main advantage agaisnt linux is that we dont need to install any of the additional software

Like in case of windows we dont get MS Office or Nero or any messenger but in linux we get Open office, Pidgin and Brasero DVD Burner

Secondly we see that linux is fast as compared to Windows

You have given your two cents ... but where are your answers to the questionnaire?

No, it isn't the case.

You have used Windows all your life and never bothered to give Linux a try it deserves. A little different way of doing things doesn't translate into X being easier than Y. Ease is more related to usability.

abslutely right ... narrow minded individual..

 

[Rahim]

Queries from staticsid answered without bias by Rahim
How long have you been using Linux?
3-4 Years (cant rmember the exact year)

How long have you been using Windows?
7 Years

Which OS did you begin using first?
MS Windows Me

Objectives (Please provide a short explanation for your experiences in each of the provided tasks):

1. When you installed Linux/Windows, which one did you find easier to install?
Windows is like Israel of OS, kicking out others rather than accomodating other OS. I choose Linux here.

2. Which OS provided the best default programs post installation?
Windows(vanilla) cannot hold a light to Linux. Linux promises you a complater Desktop while Windows provide only the OS.

3. Which of the OS's provided the best default web browser based on 1.functionality, 2.security, and 3.user-friendliness?
Linux and the browser would be Firefox.

4. Which OS did you find better to customize based on how easy it was to customize, the amount of visual and audible appeal, and the variety of customization available for the OS.
Linux all the way.

5. Which OS did you find it easier to add new programs based on how easy it was to find the software, how easy it was to install.
Both OS provides easy way of installing the applications.

6. Which OS provided a better networking experience in terms of security, setting up a LAN (wired and wireless), printer (network or direct) and functionality.
Windows is easier to setup Networking.

7. Which OS is a better base for productivity, whether it be programming,
writing, graphical design, etc. ( It can be a combination of these if you do more than one. Feel free to add your own.)
Windows considering that professional application are available only on that platform.

8. Which OS provided better file and folder management based on copying
and moving files, finding your files, adding and deleting files.
Here a Desktop Environment like KDE kicks Windows where it hurts.

9. Which OS was easier to maintain based on scanning/removing viruses and malware, defragmenting and cleaning up disk space, and backing up your information.
Linux and it is free of viruses and malwares.

10. Which OS do you find easier to troubleshoot based on man/info/help pages, working out issues on your own, and online help like forums and online
documentation.
Hmm,,,,this is a tough one. I cant answer this one.

11. Which OS provided the most stability and performance based on cpu usage, peripheral hardware compatibility (IE: mouse, tablet, webcam), software and OS freezing, crashing, locking-up, and hardware compatibility.
Linux.

12. Anything additional worth a mention as far as this comparison between Linux and Windows goes?

Linux is not terminal-only OS for geeks with long hair and bad hygiene.
Linux is not 2nd grade OS as most of Windows fanboys try to label this wonderful OS.

 

[desiibond]

1. When you installed Linux/Windows, which one did you find easier to install?

Windows 7

2. Which OS provided the best default programs post installation?

Ubuntu and SuSe


3. Which of the OS's provided the best default web browser based on 1.functionality, 2.security, and 3.user-friendliness?

firefix bundled with linux is far better in every feature compared to IE8. IE9 should turn the scales in windows favour.


4. Which OS did you find better to customize based on how easy it was to customize, the amount of visual and audible appeal, and the variety of customization available for the OS.

definitely linux.

5. Which OS did you find it easier to add new programs based on how easy it was to find the software, how easy it was to install.

thanks to ununtu software centre, i can now do one click software installation and it alos holds huge repository of softwares, making it very easy when compared to winodws s/w install.


6. Which OS provided a better networking experience in terms of security, setting up a LAN (wired and wireless), printer (network or direct) and functionality.

7. Which OS is a better base for productivity, whether it be programming,
writing, graphical design, etc. ( It can be a combination of these if you do more than one. Feel free to add your own.)

windows is still the best os when it comes to productivity and plug-n-play. programminag and 3d design are areas where windows lead by a mile.


8. Which OS provided better file and folder management based on copying
and moving files, finding your files, adding and deleting files.

windows 7.

9. Which OS was easier to maintain based on scanning/removing viruses and malware, defragmenting and cleaning up disk space, and backing up your information.

linux. virus is virtually non existant, the amount of free tools for disc mgmt make linux a clutter free os.

10. Which OS do you find easier to troubleshoot based on man/info/help pages, working out issues on your own, and online help like forums and online
documentation.

definigtely linux.

11. Which OS provided the most stability and performance based on cpu usage, peripheral hardware compatibility (IE: mouse, tablet, webcam), software and OS freezing, crashing, locking-up, and hardware compatibility.

linux. but windows hass light edge in hardware compatibility.

12. Anything additional worth a mention as far as this comparison between Linux and Windows goes?

 

[cyberjar09]

desiibond : you failed to report your experience in using the above mentioned OSs ... look to the first 3 questions ..

 

[sakumar79]

I think all of us (including the OP, myself and the rest of us who have posted) have gotten too confused... Firstly, we talk about OOBE (Out of Box experience)... Then, if anybody (some of the posters, including myself) has mentioned that productivity and programming wise, Windows is better because of better software availability, there is a inconsistency because this will not be OOBE...

IMHO, there is no point going into OOBE... There are two types of people that are the majority of computer users - those who can do basic install, etc themselves, and those who cannot... The third type, which probably a lot of digitians are, the kind who can do more than just the basic install - those who can trouble shoot, tinker, etc...- this type is a minority...

But, whatever the target type of people this survey is aimed at, there is no sense comparing OOBE experience because (atleast almost) nobody using Windows uses it without installing additional software... For the average home user, many of the Linux distros install all that are needed for their daily use including office suite, etc... So, for Linux, since it is open source and free, it is possible for people to be satisfied with OOBE...

But just imagine what would happen if Windows started bundling a costlier version of Windows OS - say a Windows Office Edition - in which the MS Office suite is preinstalled... Can you imagine the number of anti-Trust lawsuits that would be piled up against them?

Hence, IMHO, it is not possible for Windows to provide the same OOBE as Linux, but that should not be the issue, because the main comparison should lie in the end experience...

This is where the three types of people will have different experience, and this grouping should be clearly identified through the answers and end user experience for both OSes should be compared accordingly for each type separately...

Arun

 

[cyberjar09]

But just imagine what would happen if Windows started bundling a costlier version of Windows OS - say a Windows Office Edition - in which the MS Office suite is preinstalled... Can you imagine the number of anti-Trust lawsuits that would be piled up against them?

I see what you mean bu would I be right in saying that the anti-trust case was because Microsoft din't allow ofr the uninstallaion of software like IE and WMP that came bundled with Windows?