SE G900 or HTC Touch or HTC Touch Diamond

[krups]

Hi All,

I am confused about which mobile is better, considering performance+battery+music+organizer+touchscreen+wifi at average scales.

Sony Ericsson G900, key features
- OS: Symbian -> UIQ 3
- Touch screen + Traditional Keypad
- Notes Application
- Compact design
- 5MP Camera (tho' Avg quality, doesn't matter)
- Wifi
- Memory Card Slot (upto 8GB)
Approx Rs. 20k

HTC Touch, key features
- OS: Windows 6.0
- Touch screen
- Lots of applications as its windows
- 2MP Camera (Good Quality)
- Wifi
- Memory Card Slot (upto 8GB)
Approx Rs. 15k

HTC Touch Diamond, key features
- OS: Windows 6.1
- Touch screen
- Lots of applications as its windows
- 3.15MP Camera (Better Quality)
- Wifi
- Memory upto 4GB (Not upgradable)
- Accelerometer
- Ultimate GUI (TouchFlo 3D)
Approx Rs. 25k

For SE G900, I have heard it lags it is very slow. Also future for UIQ 3 is no more.
For HTC Touch, Slow Processor (201MHz), Screen resolution is Lower, Touch sometimes lag.
For HTC Touch, Faster Processor (528MHz)+Ultimate LCD Display Quality, but poor battery life. I have heard, it lasts hardly a day for average usage.

Budget isn't matters, but which amongst these outcomes with best value for the price.

I have referred following sites for reviews
-gsmarena.com
-phonegg.com
-mobile-review.com
-cnet.net

Thanks a lot.

 

[dreamcatcher]

Dont get the G900.Its quite buggy and n firmwares have been released as yet.My friend bought and sold it within 2 months.
I suggest you look for the HTC Touch Diamond. But, bear in mind the HTC is very laggy and is not too responsive when it comes to multitasking, the lack of a keypad is also a disadvantage.
I suggest you look for the P1i, a satisfied user myself. A brilliant piece with a qwerty keyboard which wont leave you in jeopardy.

 

[Coool]

Htc Touch diamond..

 

[krazzy]

I would suggest waiting for the Nokia 5800 XpressMusic.

 

[ico]

I would also suggest Nokia 5800 XpressMusic.

BTW, why have you used so many emoticons in your post.......

 

[pickster]

BTW, why have you used so many emoticons in your post.......

to indicate what he likes and dislikes, obviously.

 

[toofan]

Motorola too have a set in range of 16000. Its too a good phone.

 

[krups]

Thank you all.

Btw, I am using nokia since many years and want a shift to some new environment; So purposely I would not go for nokia this time. Also release date for 5800 is around Feb 09, I require phone sooner..

Have anybody experienced the touchflo 3d of diamond..?? Bcos when I looked at mobile store it was mindblowing GUI. The way SMS are poped up, mail box, contacts, browser, photo gallery, etc.. It is exactly the same as displayed at *www.htc.com/in/product.aspx?id=48118 :roll:

But I need reviews from some ppl who are actually using the HTC Diamond phone.

I got one more -ve comment for SE G900, thanks dreamcatcher; so probably I have made my mind not to go for SE G900.

@Gagandeep: Smiles' are the emotions I felt looking at the features..

 

[drck]

as i mentioned in my thread u can increase overall performance of htc touch.. including touch responce and faster OS... obviously for that u need to read and spend some time with wm. and flashing with custom os means u ll loose ur waranty.. (if u care abt it)...

 

[IronManForever]

Touch Diamond; I wouldnt say go for it; I'd say JUMP for it!! As you can afford it, why not get it? VGA resolution and TouchFLO 3D, my-my..
About battery, yeah; maybe because of screen resolution and faster components as well as dedicated GFX processor. Its the same story about many high-enders.. iPhone, N82, both have a similar story.

HTC Touch though it has ample features, sucks due to low hardware specfications. WM is a pretty demanding OS and it worsens the scenario. Though if you re-flash it with custom firmware made by XDA-Devs; it wont be laggy at all.

And BTW its camera also aint good(which you said). Lags like hell for anything other than outdoor shots. Also the colour reproduction is well below mark.

 

[krups]

Interesting.... Diamond is the best i think.. its a iphone killer too.

Also i have sniffed that bigger battery (1800mA) is available in the market with replaced backpanel making diamond 3mm thicker.. Though you get double battery life in return..

In Ahmedabad, it is available locked with Airtel .. I don't want to shift to airtel so I need to unlock it..

I saw it in showroom, it has one menu option called "Airtel" . So after i unlock the phone will it be there only?? Any idea??

 

[Cool G5]

I would suggest you to wait for Nokia 5800XM.

or else get the N82 Black

 

[IronManForever]

^^ What I wanna say is that he has never bought anything other than Nokia... Its about time for a change.. Windows Mobile is a great and much powerful platform.. Let him wander about in unchartered territory..

 

[uppalpankaj]

Wait for the 5800xm. Once its is released then u can directly compare htc and 5800 and buy whichever suits you...

 

[Ganeshkumar]

Another vote for HTC touch diamond...

Grab it.. as budget doesnt matter for you...

BTW: I am planning to get HTC touch, but no stock in chennai

 

[krups]

Nokia 5800XM seems to be good and also better battery life ; but i am sure.. i will miss the TouchFlo 3D technology, compatibility, large number of freeware applications as compared to WM Touch Diamond. And fortunately it is going to release in Feb or Mar 09, till which I cant wait.

@Ganeshkumar: I have also inquired about HTC Touch, here in ahmedabad too its out of stock and its currently best selling WM phone.

 

[Power UP]

Nokia 5800XM seems to be good and also better battery life ; but i am sure.. i will miss the TouchFlo 3D technology, compatibility, large number of freeware applications as compared to WM Touch Diamond. And fortunately it is going to release in Feb or Mar 09, till which I cant wait.

Its most probably going to be launched this month (November).

*www.radioandmusic.com/content/editorial/gadget-gyan/nokia-unleash-5800-november

 

[krups]

Nokia seems to be juicy.. but you never feel the essence which you get on wm. Not everybody can feel the same .

The only battery issue of HTC Diamond kicks.. otherwise its outstanding..

No matter now the battle remains for Touch vs Diamond.. Which out of two wins for Price / Value ratio??

 

[dhan_shh]

Recent "HTC Touch HD" looks very impressive: with 3.8" screen,288MB RAM will be a real competitor.

No Doubt,really SEXY!

*i483.photobucket.com/albums/rr199/dhan_shh/htc-touch-hd-02.jpg

*i483.photobucket.com/albums/rr199/dhan_shh/htc-touch-hd-03.jpg

 

[krups]

HTC HD is undoubtedly greatttt!! But it is not launched in India and converting foreign currency its price would be around 40K which is too high..

So sticking to Diamond