I havent followed this thread at all... But I will now!
My personal recommendations :
Anurag Kashyap's
Gulaal - Wonder why great movies disappear of the cinema halls sooner than u cn bat an eyelid?
DEV D
No Smoking - Got 2-1/2 stars in most reviews, if nt less! I"d give it at least a 4 on 5.
The imdb top 250 gives a good idea of the best of mainstream cinema.
If any1 interested in Art films, one can try any movie by Jean-Luc Godard, Satyajit Ray, and a few others.
Sergio Leone's : Once Upon A Time In America is also very good. Its 3.5 hrs, and ive seen abt 3 but I like it a lot.
One last one : Taxi Driver by Martin Scorcese! 10.1/10!
And Yup, Slumdog deserved the Oscar! No great movie wins it anyway! Wonder why movies like The Dark Knight and Gran Torino were ignored for the oscars???x(