Maharashtra bans beef, 5 years jail, Rs 10,000 fine for possession or sale

OP
Nanducob

Nanducob

Wise Old Owl
To make things more believable they should also issue a public notice citing the overly religious remarks made by Bjp leaders were disposed when they were drunk :lol:
 
GhorMaanas

GhorMaanas

The Vagrant Seeker
Anorion said:
Ah that clears it up a bit. Otherwise this seemed like a senseless move.
Click to expand...

the govt. a few weeks back had hinted that it aims & plans to make cattle-rearing & (up)keeping (productive as well as unyielding) profitable & beneficial for their owners, and, as i had indicated in an earlier post of mine, one thread in this section here is related & aligned to that purpose (the 'Gaunyle' one).
 
Desmond

Desmond

Destroy Erase Improve
Staff member
Admin
GG Kerala

What Beef Ban? Hindu-Muslim Union Over Feasting On Beef Is The Cool New Form Of Protest In Kerala
 
Ronnie11

Ronnie11

Judgement Time!!
REDHOTIRON2004 said:
So according to you killing animals for there beef and all is a sign of being progressive(sic)?

Faith or not. Killing of animals should be avoided at all cost. You have a bigger brain and have power and means to kill innocent animals doesn't make you progressive. Feelings like empathy, sympathy etc are the main pillars on which a progressive society should be based on and that includes plants and animals as well.

But, with your limited thinking killing of animals unnecessarily is the sign of an advanced society. I completely disagree to your point of view.

Have you ever heard about ecological balance? Do you know that in coastal regions in the past farmers used to fish only the quality they needed. They also used to feed them and make sure that there future generations have enough sustenance opportunity. Also, nothing used to lay to waste. Even the bones and skin of the animals that were killed were used in one way or the other.

But, now, people like your kind of mantality kill mindlessly for profit. So many species have been made extinct because you think they are not worth the time and effort.

Atleast here one of the main sources of wastage would be kept out. Preservation is extremely important. Because human thirst knows no boundaries.

If government won't have made it illegal to cut trees in the cities. Then there won't have been a single tree left. And your kind of people were behind the bad situation of the environment and ecology.
Click to expand...

I am sorry but this is a bizarre defense. Where did progressiveness come in all of this.You make meat consumers sound as if they are cruel people who can't feel sympathy. What advanced society? We have too many important issues already to deal with here than beef. Poverty, unemployment etc.
Well the farmer's family is growing and self sustainable quantity never works. How will he make money. Send his kids for education.

Corporate greed is a different topic altogether. Beef sector in India is mostly an unorganised sector.So many species have gone extinct due to poaching, leather etc, again how is this relevant here.

Lol, so you are comparing cutting trees to beef. The last line makes no sense whatsoever.
 
GhorMaanas

GhorMaanas

The Vagrant Seeker
DeSmOnD dAvId said:
GG Kerala

What Beef Ban? Hindu-Muslim Union Over Feasting On Beef Is The Cool New Form Of Protest In Kerala
Click to expand...

had read about it 1-2 days back. hand-choppers and commie-marauders making merry in their backyard. attempting a similar stunt at Harayana and Maharashtra would attract some better-deserved 'warmth'.
if only they had showed such a display of 'unity' and 'je suis charle' at Shirin Dalvi's sacking and arrest, or against the 1L INR and 'gift of islamic sword' fatwa for the head of Mufti Mohammad Iliyaas!
 
R

REDHOTIRON2004

Journeyman
Ronnie11 said:
I am sorry but this is a bizarre defense. Where did progressiveness come in all of this.You make meat consumers sound as if they are cruel people who can't feel sympathy. What advanced society? We have too many important issues already to deal with here than beef. Poverty, unemployment etc.
Well the farmer's family is growing and self sustainable quantity never works. How will he make money. Send his kids for education.

Corporate greed is a different topic altogether. Beef sector in India is mostly an unorganised sector.So many species have gone extinct due to poaching, leather etc, again how is this relevant here.

Lol, so you are comparing cutting trees to beef. The last line makes no sense whatsoever.
Click to expand...

The progressive part was in response to mohit9206 where he mentioned how progressive nation should be. Do read my reply fully before commenting.

Now, comming on to your more practical aspect. Yes, farmers have to send there children to the most reputed school and also need to have cars and a good big house. Agreed!
But, doesn't everybody want all of that? There are limited resources with multiple uses, and in the not so prefect world everybody doesn't get everything. We have to accept that as human needs have no bound.

My point is that. A farmer or any other person who don't have much money to spare should send his children to public school or colleges. Or private schools or colleges according to his paying capacity. Similarly he can own a maruti instead of a mercedes or a small house instead of a bungalow.

Everbody can not have the same thing. And there are similar things available at various price points. So, saying that sustainability cannot be afforded is not true.

We need to understand our responsibility to our future generations. And just because we are greedy doesn't mean that we use all the resources available at our disposal at once. That's not the way our future generations could survive. Dont have such a skewed/narrow view.

Well beef as with all other kind of meat including fish, also need to be used in a certain limit. A lot of fish species have too gone extinct because of there meat. At that time too people used to think they are unlimited just like the trees. And now some that are left is because the government have banned there catching. Some more examples of human greed are tigers, lions, dolphins etc-2 list is endless.

Just like cutting trees people have killed them in such huge numbers that there whole habitat was destroyed forever. And banning is one way to stop that.

Its not only about the beef. You must make sure that you should never waste meat or anything of any animal who was killed because of your needs. And please atleast leave sufficient resources for the future generations. You are just a tenant on earth and not its owner. Like a guard its everbody responsibility to save much for our future generations. And if you or the government or lawmakers dont have time to think about the future then we already are a doomed species.
 
Last edited:
SaiyanGoku

SaiyanGoku

kamehameha!!
Nanducob said:
Haryana makes sale of beef a non-bailable offence - The Times of India
thanks modi :(
Click to expand...

*fbcdn-sphotos-h-a.akamaihd.net/hphotos-ak-xtp1/v/t1.0-9/11061268_737801333001547_1818250643750870293_n.jpg?oh=6e765e469d362689dcd4c5494b5cc8a6&oe=55B07047&__gda__=1438163313_ea3dff3895661086bfed7c23a09187ab
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom