Re: All Graphics Cards related queries here.
ooo next time i will write a post ......i'll write its not meant for mr. tkin
Ouch!!Nice Post but a few points,
i m sorry there were none for u !!!
1.Why is that Tom's Hardware always comes up with these wonderful ATI results? Most sites I have seen shows that the 9800GTX+ has a clear edge over HD4850 by 5%.
its ur personal view obviously most people around the world doesn't share that spending extra $30 is worth for 5% increase! .
A few games either favour ATI or nVidia so charts based on them are not so trustworthy.
oh now thats something new here i was not aware of ..perhaps new rules should be defined by Mr. tkin here so that all cards can b benchmarked in a fair manner ...
the rule according to mr.Tkin goes --all games either should favour nVidia or ATI only then bechmarking results can be fair !
2.The Entire test configuration SUCKS big time.
CPU -Intel Core 2 Extreme X6800 @ 2.93 GHz (11x 266 MHz),
Socket 775, 1.28 V, 65 nm, 4096 KB L2 cache
FSB -1066 MHz (4x 266 MHz)
Motherboard -Asus P5E3 Deluxe, PCIe 2.0 2x16, ICH9R
65nm DUAL CORE CPU with only 4mb Cache and 1066MHz FSB? That's the biggest bottleneck right there.
Is it me or is Tom's Hardware running out of money.
Its essential to do the tests with QExtreme/E8500 proccy, all sites do this, too bad Tom can't afford one.
obviously it shows how much do u know know about CPU's and its working in depth,why shouldn't u go and apply a job at Intel,or some other review site which says 9800gtx+ is out of the world card! ..they can use ur expertise!
3.9800GTX+ is in the charts of all sites doing the tests after its release, either Tom broke theirs or nVidia didn't think necessary to send one. Too bad they didn't qualify.
i will let it pass just to say even HD4870x2 didn't make it!
4.9800GTX+ is probably the 6th generation
everybody knows what generation it is ...so i guess no need to say anything about it !
5.Read the user comments if you don't trust me, its clear that Tom messed up big time, I don't trust their results(even the ATI ones, seems some of the old ones are too low, I used ATI till date and don't think they should be that low)
as i said above u have better expertise than them ...and obviously that was not for u ....for u some great sites need to come down from heaven
6.I laugh at a site that says that HD 4870 CF is same as HD4870x2(scroll down the user comments a little bit and this guy from Tom's, named cangelini wrote that)
after all world in not low on cynics u can also find a friend there ...its not a miracle i guess!
7.HD4870x2 not there, seems its also not worthy of being in the fabled 5 generations of graphics card.
reason for it being not included was this test took 500 hrs ..and that will be about a month ..thats the reason for old catalyst drivers and not including HD4870x2!
8.No. of transistors = "754MB"?? (Do they know what they are saying?)
clearly shows if one is after picking mistakes ...one wouldn't leave a typo!..now thats called cynical ...
Final Conclusion:- Tom's are just a bunch of kids poking around doing a few tests here and there not to mention the fact that they are not properly armed to do the tests.
offcourse those bunch of kids are much respected than u,well by most of the people except cynical friends of urs ...!
P.S- No hard feelings Please.
same to u !
Give me some hard evidence that HD4850 towers 9800GTX+ in almost all games.
why should i ever do that ..thats a waste of time...and what do i have to prove to u anyway ...all the people with brain have understood knows where HD4850 belongs and gone quiet seeing ur attitude...moreover "pagal kutte to nahin kata mujhe"..so that i will do that!
I have one that shows 9800GTX+ at an advantage(I don't know if they are nVidia fanboys but other card results seems O.K):-
*www.legitreviews.com/article/731/1/
now this is the portion which made me laugh the most among otherwise completely hilarious post!
now really i should say u should have read and seen the review from ur eyes wide open before posting this....
before i start let me laugh out loud!!!! ha ha ha
1st benchmark - tomb raider anniversary (is this really a game to benchmark ??? strange choice ..just shows the level of legitreviews ..)
@1900x1200
9800gtx+ --->99.9 FPS
HD4850 ----->120.6 FPS
20 FPS more for HD4850... 20% increase over covoted (according to Mr .Tkin ) 9800gtx+
2nd benchmark - company of heroes
@1900x1200
9800gtx+---->41.4 FPS
HD4850--->34.6 FPS
9800gtx+ is ahead by 6.8 FPS
3rd benchmark -world in conflict
@1900x1200
9800gtx+ ----->24 FPS
HD4850 ------> 29 FPS
5 FPS less for 9800gtx+
4th becnhmark- S.T.A.L.K.E.R.
@1900x1200
9800 gtx+ ---->107.1 FPS
HD4850 ----> 95 FPS
12 FPS more for 9800gtx+
5th bentchmark - BIOSHOCK
9800gtx+ ----->49.33 FPS
HD4850 ------>47.467 FPS
1.863 FPS more for 9800gtx+
6th benchmark - CRYSIS
@1900x1200 -very high
9800gtx+ ------->16.8 FPS
HD4850 -------->15.867 FPS
0.933 FPS more for 9800gtx+
7th benchmark - Call Of Duty 4
@1900x1200
9800gtx+---->41.8 FPS
HD4850 ----->43.5 FPS
1.7 FPS less for 9800gtx+
total average FPS for 9800gtx+ in all games = 380.33
total average FPS for HD4850 in all games = 386.034
9800gtx+ is 5.704 total average FPS behind HD4850...
i hope u can calculate the percentage decrease for 9800gtx+
i don't see a 5 % increase here on the review provided by you ...unless i don't know maths or did something wrong here !!!
now in India the price of
HD4850 is 9.25k
9800gtx+ is 12.5k
9800gtx+ being 3.25k more costly than HD4850 gives above performance ...clear winner only in two games company of heroes and stalker out of 7 games ...unless 1.863FPS , 0.9 FPS really mean something to u....i would say thats almost equal cos test system parameters can be variable.
those who have eyes can see it ...who is the real winner
and this is the performance in old games...newer games i don't know what will happen to 9800gtx+
HD4850 is most VFM no doubt, but performance wise 9800GTX+ rules, not to mention the good overclocking headroom it has over the HD4850.
taling about overclocking our own forum member(regenade) has a overclocking result for HD4850 ...now try getting that with ur 9800gtx+
15683 3d mark 06 scores !
*www.imgx.org/public/view/full/10985
copy that !!!
I'm not a nVidia fanboy, writing this post with an ATI X200 Chipset mobo(Intel D102GGC2) with an ATI X1900XTX installed. Just clearing the facts.
not clearing facts just being motivated by bragging of friends ..its all about ur personal ego!
Anyway, nice post imgame2 bro
alas it wasn't for u ...
but to make things clear i will not be again talking over this topic ever again hence it was long so i m sorry to other people who had to see such a long thread!!!!