Firstly, I never intended to bring up Chelsea.
It only came up when
ico posted that Ferdinand didnt do much till 2006 and the justification for that, at some level, being the fact that Chelsea dominated the league for 2 seasons before that.
The reply to that was pointing out that the weakness for Manchester United at that time wasnt Ferdinand in defense, but the midfield (silvestre at LB wasnt much help either)
19 teams didnt play well and one team walked away? doenst make sense!!
Lyon won 7 french leagues in a row because there was hardly any competition
Porto did the same for large parts of the last 2 decades in Portugal
The cheslea squad of 09-10 was better than the squad they had in 05-06, but the reason they won the league more comfortably in 05-06 was because the rest of the league failed to respond to the new standards chelsea had set.
This whole thing, btw is a completely different argument
and while we are at it, Chelsea played some beautiful football in 04-05 with Cole, Duff and Robben in their side. Being more adventurous didnt cost them.
What cost them was the emergence of ronaldo, the improvement in the rest of the league and the decline of makelele (who was brilliant in his prime, chelsea still havent replaced him)
There werent as many easy games for chelsea anymore and they started dropping points ..
That is still going on, the rest of the league is still getting better and the top teams, in some respect, have hit the ceiling .. Thats why teams are dropping so many points this season (FFP+squad cap and increased TV revenue for the bottom sides)
And returning to Carragher, he really isnt in the same level as the other defenders you have mentioned
Arsenal reached a CL finals with Senderos in the heart of their defense, that doesnt make him quality player
He is a fan favorite at liverpool and has been there all his career, but he is not a great CB.. A very good one for a top 4 side, so for Liverpool, he is great
Nowhere near as good as Vidic,Rio,Terry,Carvalho,Gallas
King and Woodgate are very very good, but have constantly been injured.
Bloody hell, that was long
Off to watch the matches..