A weird situation involving SSD and a HDD

[swiftshashi]

Guys,a bit of trouble here-While Playing videos(which is on my HDD BTW with the replaced cable,SATA 3.0Gbps port),I encounter a sound creaking sort of sound accompanied with video freezing for a millisecond.
It is only with my HDD,when I copy it to my SSD,no issue is there.

 

[swiftshashi]

Guys,another issue.
Just to recap,I have a dual SSD-HDD setup.Got a new cable and HDD for it as it was making some clicking noises.
The HDD was a new one,manufactured in Nov 13.
Everything was fine untill yesterday.
I noticed Reallocated Sectors count value today.How come its the same value which my previous HDD had got??Is it because I used it in train last night??However only value has come,no freezing or clicks whatsoever. What might be the reason behind this??