rohanbee the only reason altec and creative have setup their plant in china is due to the cheap and hard working labour easily available there....the chinese and japenese ppl are hard working and dedicated by birth if u ask me....rest assure that these premium brands carry around ammendable QC....
the reasons one shud not buy average quality speakers like intex and mercury even if u've a low budget are:
1. the first reason is the biggest reason itself....they are average performing and cannot match the audio quality of well known brands..
2. they are bound to produce faults...so lots of servicing is required which adds up to the later costs..
3. their after sales service is just like the way they sound....average!
4. they generaly have low life and in most of the cases the amplifier is dead after 2 yrs..
5. most of these speakers place their volume controls on the subwoofer which is absolutely FRUSTRATING if u ask me....
6. due to their technology constarints they can in no way focus on the whole sound frequency spectrum...they either sound too sharp or too shady or too flat(weak bass)...the blending of different sound frequencies is literally non existent here....which makes me come to the pt. that why intex is not good for mp3s as suggested by some...
actually if u ask me the most challenging part for any speaker is to ouput rich quality mp3s....dvds and games genreally have more dynamic and ambient sounds so even an above average speakers can produce decent output and their weakness is not noticeable all the time but in mp3s such is not the case....coz its a compressed format first of all and secondly music gives emphasis to different notes...like guitar, basson and tabla...now they will sound good only if speaker has efficient frequency response which is only possible in well know brands such as altec, creative bose, klipsch etc.
so i wud suggest that u go with altec 221 if u have a budget of 2.5K and if u can strech ur budget arnd 3K then definately go for ATP3....
altec lanisng AHP512 headphones is also a good choice if u've a low budget...
ENjoy...
nice writeup!!
well, i would like to add a point here.
couple of months back, i made a visit to B&W showroom in US. they had this new speaker set along with an amplifier. for the demo, they had a CD, labeled "20kHz - 20Hz". it just had a disturbing sound where the frequency went from 20kHz to 20Hz in a smooth curve. the demo manual said that under no normalization(equalizers, epicenters, other sound adjustments), the output should be uniform for all the frequencies in the given spectrum. when the CD played, i could hear the same volume throughout the track. they enen had a decibel meter, which was constant at 80dB. recently, i downloaded the same track from the internet and played it on, my altec lancing atp3, my neighbour's "DTS" Intex speakers(5.1), my car's 800W amp+woofer system.
the intex was the worst performer with a very bad freqiency responce(there was no sound for the first 3-4 seconds) and the woofer coil almost popped out in the "low" end. the sound disappeared many times in between. the sound peaked at moderate high and moderate low.
Next was my car(unfortunately): the sound was quite good in the highs(thanks to the Pioneer amp and legendry TS20), however, the sound shallowed a bit in the upper mids, and there was a peak in the extreme lows(that wasnt bad after all, i could see the side mirror vibrating).
best performer was the Altec Lancing, i am proud to say, very close to perfect.
as per the decision, i think, it's better to invest on quality than quantity.
p.s. dont get fooled by PMPO.