Windows 7: Microsoft's Linux killer?

Status
Not open for further replies.

kalpik

In Pursuit of "Happyness"
Hmm.. People, please stop the fighting!

P.S.: I could also install ubuntu in about 15 minutes on my machine using a live DVD.
 

chandru.in

In the zone
P.S.: I could also install ubuntu in about 15 minutes on my machine using a live DVD.
:)

Whether MS fears it or not, Preston Gralla seems to be greatly scared of Linux's success to ensure market for his books. He is digging out old stories and claims.

*blogs.computerworld.com/one_more_reason_linux_must_fear_windows_7

But ASUS CEO had clearly explained at least for EEE, returns rates were similar for XP and Linux versions. I guess MSI just messed up the UI.
 
Last edited:
F

FilledVoid

Guest
Congratulations. Join the club of users who continue misinterpreting others' words and go all whammy over it.
If the club includes me then Yes Id love to be in it.
He is simply quoting the time it takes to install ubuntu and get it to a "fully" usable state, as in <including> codecs, flash, etc. I too take an additional 15 min time to get those stuff installed.
Are you stating that he included package install times like Flash and codecs in the 20 minutes too :D . Cause I definitely don't see that happening either. I believe he just referred to updating his package lists.
If somebody insults a particular type of windows users, it does not mean the whole windows user community is being insulted.
And who on earth gave you permission to insult that particular Windows user? What makes you think that he needs the insulting ?
I'd want to call it a lie after sitting beside me while I'm installing and if I fail to install in 20 mins.
Unfortunately geographical factors do prevent that from happening else Id be more than happy to drive there to see this 20 minute install procedure. Hence I call it based on my experience. My experience tells me that there is no way you got an Ubuntu up and running for a Live CD in 20 minutes. If I hadn't done a reinstall of Arch I probably would have installed Hardy Heron and confirmed again.
Yes Live CD did give me those time but I did not count boot time of Live CD. I asked you to use Alternate only if you want to count boot time of CD in install time.
As I said I have no comment on the Alternate CD install. I pointed at the comment on the Live CD install and that is what I still stick too.
Good but don't count boot time of Live CD. Don't count time taken by you to re-arrange partitions (I have a very clear pre-made partition scheme which I use for every new version). Don't count more than 30 secs for entering user name and password during install.
No I dont intend on weaseling my way out of it. In other words I dont intend on taking 1 minute coming up with a weird login name or hostname.
 

chandru.in

In the zone
Are you stating that he included package install times like Flash and codecs in the 20 minutes too :D . Cause I definitely don't see that happening either. I believe he just referred to updating his package lists.
You are right I did not include installing any additional package just the plain install including refreshing of package list.

Unfortunately geographical factors do prevent that from happening else Id be more than happy to drive there to see this 20 minute install procedure. Hence I call it based on my experience. My experience tells me that there is no way you got an Ubuntu up and running for a Live CD in 20 minutes. If I hadn't done a reinstall of Arch I probably would have installed Hardy Heron and confirmed again.
And you say this even after kalpik confirmed my statement. And in any case, even if you fail 100 times to achieve it, you have no reason to claim I was lying. I did it and it is my experience (now Kalpik's too).

As I said I have no comment on the Alternate CD install. I pointed at the comment on the Live CD install and that is what I still stick too.
I'll stick with same too. But in that case don't add Live CD boot time to install time. If you want to include boot time, use alternate CD simple.
 
If the club includes me then Yes Id love to be in it.

:|

Are you stating that he included package install times like Flash and codecs in the 20 minutes too :D . Cause I definitely don't see that happening either. I believe he just referred to updating his package lists.

Seriously. I DID take that much time on BSNL H500. I just used the IIT Chennai mirrors. 210kbps min and 240kbps max :D

And who on earth gave you permission to insult that particular Windows user? What makes you think that he needs the insulting ?

I am refering to a pompous i-know-everything-in-the-world type of guy I personally know. I now realise that I should not have mentioned it here.
 
F

FilledVoid

Guest
And you say this even after kalpik confirmed my statement. And in any case, even if you fail 100 times to achieve it, you have no reason to claim I was lying. I did it and it is my experience (now Kalpik's too).
Yes as you claimed from your experience so did I. Since I guess kalpik can back your claim I guess it might be right then. My apologies.
I'll stick with same too. But in that case don't add Live CD boot time to install time. If you want to include boot time, use alternate CD simple.
Nope, if I intend to judge Windows on their whole install procedure the I intend to do the same on any OS I use, Including the boot up time.
 

kalpik

In Pursuit of "Happyness"
Ok.. Let me clarify.. I think it depends a lot on your hardware.. I guess my hardware is more "linux friendly" than yours, probably that's why the huge difference in installation time :)
 

RCuber

The Mighty Unkel!!!
Staff member
:|
I am refering to a pompous i-know-everything-in-the-world type of guy I personally know. I now realise that I should not have mentioned it here.
How do we know your i-know-everything-in-the-world type of guy you personally know :p. as per your statement you were refering every windows user as a n00b, and when some questions the statement you say I was not refering to those guys and blah blah :| , please think before making a statement, make sure you dont make a fool of yourself by such comments.
 

chandru.in

In the zone
Yes as you claimed from your experience so did I. Since I guess kalpik can back your claim I guess it might be right then. My apologies.
Ah finally thanks for taking back your claims that I was lying.

Nope, if I intend to judge Windows on their whole install procedure the I intend to do the same on any OS I use, Including the boot up time.
You are welcome to do it. But compare apples to apples in terms of install medium.

Live CD of Ubuntu - Live CD of Windows (If one is ever made)
Alternate CD of Ubuntu - Normal install DVD of Windows

Come on man what is it that you don't get? Loading a fully functional desktop is several times intensive than loading just an installer.

Ok.. Let me clarify.. I think it depends a lot on your hardware.. I guess my hardware is more "linux friendly" than yours, probably that's why the huge difference in installation time :)
I agree with that too. I was irritated only coz FilledVoid outright denied my statement and called it a lie. But yeah before I upgraded my system recently I cherry picked most Ubuntu friendly hardware components. So it very much possible that Ubuntu came bundled high performing drivers for my system.
 
Last edited:

Faun

Wahahaha~!
Staff member
Ok.. Let me clarify.. I think it depends a lot on your hardware.. I guess my hardware is more "linux friendly" than yours, probably that's why the huge difference in installation time :)
yep...exactly. Just get the right piece of hardware before banging your head :D
Though I still dont think that new BIOS update fixes the BIOS bug for Debian lenny netinst discs :))

Btw Flledvoid, I think majority of users here said that it took less than 30 mins but still nevermind:wink:

Btw it's all fine until you take it verbally personal...lolz
 
How do we know your i-know-everything-in-the-world type of guy you personally know :p. as per your statement you were refering every windows user as a n00b, and when some questions the statement you say I was not refering to those guys and blah blah :| , please think before making a statement, make sure you dont make a fool of yourself by such comments.
If thats the case, maybe its because my language is becoming worse for some reason :oops:
Time to start learning to use words better I guess.

I hope I did not offend anybody in my "out-of-context" statements.
 
F

FilledVoid

Guest
Btw Flledvoid, I think majority of users here said that it took less than 30 mins but still nevermind
Respect is earned. I take Kalpiks word with more value than I would for a majority of users theres nothing to be amazed there.
Live CD of Ubuntu - Live CD of Windows (If one is ever made)
As I said earlier I didnt judge an alternate cd ior a text install procedure or an FTP procedure. I did mention that I based my judgement on a Live CD/DVD . There is no Apples being compared here since Im not comparing Windows with Linux. All I was comparing was the Install Time. In other words Boot up -> Live CD -> Installation Procedure -> Restart -> Boot up to my desktop. I would use to include any timings incurred as the previously mentioned procedure as my judgement. How you judge Windows vs Linux is irrelative to me.
 
As I said earlier I didnt judge an alternate cd ior a text install procedure or an FTP procedure. I did mention that I based my judgement on a Live CD/DVD . There is no Apples beign compared here since Im not comparing Windows with Linux. All I was comparing was the Install Time. In other words Boot up -> Live CD -> Installation procedure -> Restart -> Boot up to my desktop. I would use to include any timings I refer to.
I noticed that ubuntu started taking LOTS of time to boot and go between install steps ever since 7.10 was released. I think its because my comp and several others' computers have hardware that causes compiz to hang and waste time.

Whats YOUR hardware configuration ?
 

chandru.in

In the zone
@FilledVoid

I was mentioning about Ubuntu getting installed much faster than Windows so obviously I did not count boot time of Live CD. It was after that post that you chipped in saying it is hard to believe. :D
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom