Suggest Component Upgrade for 80k

mukherjee

Treatment in progress...
Yes, content, was drowsy after giving 6 exams, anyway i don't like sli, too many scaling issues, heat issues etc, the lightning fits the bill, its that or the asus dc2.

June 1st plan is on, will sms mukherjee, nginx, I'll pm you.

@ mukherjee, the 590 will overshoot budget by 15k and also has vrm issues, nvidia is bringing out rev 2 of 590 due to this, i'm game for either a lightning or asus dc2.

Copy...thats why I always prefer a single card setup...whatever the gurus say...
 
OP
tkin

tkin

Back to school!!
Scaling as in some games with crappy ports will be crippled in sli mode, remember darksiders, that game had negative sli scaling for ages, a rescent new game, forgot the name had negative scaling till nvidia fixed it sometime later, i'd hate that.
 

mukherjee

Treatment in progress...
Scaling as in some games with crappy ports will be crippled in sli mode, remember darksiders, that game had negative sli scaling for ages, a rescent new game, forgot the name had negative scaling till nvidia fixed it sometime later, i'd hate that.

whatever be it...sli/xfire has its own quirks..i'm better off without that...after spending such a lot....
 

Extreme Gamer

僕はガンダム!
Vendor
tkin I said that games that are CPU intensive dont get great scaling.

Darksiders mostly runs on the CPU.hell, an i7 860 @stock + HD5770 maxes it out easily(minimum 50fps).It was not a crappy port.It just wasnt hardware intensive(the game design and art wasnt all that awesome looking).

play GPU heavy games.you will see awesome scaling in 99% of the titles.

i did say that CPU intensive and crappy ports will not get good scaling. GTAIV and EFLC are the best examples.

Look at borderlands,I get 45-70% scaling in it.Does it mean its crappy port?It is just very light on system hardware.

Then again, the 580 lightning is a great card.But please OC it to 950-1Ghz core and 4300Mhz memory.Otherwise there is no need for lightning.

EDIT:I played darksiders today (hadnt played on new PC yet albeit it had been installed) and got 90-95% scaling :)

GTX 500 doesnt have the scaling issues that plagued GTX 200.
 
Last edited:
OP
tkin

tkin

Back to school!!
tkin I said that games that are CPU intensive dont get great scaling.

Darksiders mostly runs on the CPU.hell, an i7 860 @stock + HD5770 maxes it out easily(minimum 50fps).It was not a crappy port.It just wasnt hardware intensive(the game design and art wasnt all that awesome looking).

play GPU heavy games.you will see awesome scaling in 99% of the titles.

i did say that CPU intensive and crappy ports will not get good scaling. GTAIV and EFLC are the best examples.

Look at borderlands,I get 45-70% scaling in it.Does it mean its crappy port?It is just very light on system hardware.

Then again, the 580 lightning is a great card.But please OC it to 950-1Ghz core and 4300Mhz memory.Otherwise there is no need for lightning.

EDIT:I played darksiders today (hadnt played on new PC yet albeit it had been installed) and got 90-95% scaling :)

GTX 500 doesnt have the scaling issues that plagued GTX 200.
The scaling issue got fixed in almost 3 months.

I will oc it to 900/4200 for sure, one more reason to get it, just need to sort warranty and shipping out first.
 
OP
tkin

tkin

Back to school!!
Yes but GTX 500 itself does not have issues in scaling.
Ofcourse it doesn't, it a single gpu after all, no driver level need of frame splitting or afr.

I need to contact msi about the lightning, in the meantime i'll buy the rest of my rig.
 

nginx

In the zone
I dunno but I always feel its a waste of money to buy a top of the line card with such premium price. My strategy is to always go for a reasonably priced upper midrange card and then SLI it 6 month later when the price comes down. Saves loads of money that way rather than having to spend a fortune behind a flagship model whose price/performance ratio whacked.

There are only a few games which doesn't provide good scaling. So I'm not too worried about that.

Anyway, so you're saying that the 580 is not available in Kolkata yet?
 
OP
tkin

tkin

Back to school!!
I dunno but I always feel its a waste of money to buy a top of the line card with such premium price. My strategy is to always go for a reasonably priced upper midrange card and then SLI it 6 month later when the price comes down. Saves loads of money that way rather than having to spend a fortune behind a flagship model whose price/performance ratio whacked.

There are only a few games which doesn't provide good scaling. So I'm not too worried about that.

Anyway, so you're saying that the 580 is not available in Kolkata yet?
The zotac and palit and maybe msi reference yes, msi lightning maybe not, need to verify. Maybe I need to pre order it.

SLI is good, but the non reference 560(MSI) has heat issues with sli, if you want to go sli try to get a reference card like zotac.
 

Extreme Gamer

僕はガンダム!
Vendor
MSI wont do home delivery.They will make local distributor contact you.

expect a reply MAXIMUM 3-4 days from now.

he should reply by wednesday.
 
OP
tkin

tkin

Back to school!!
MSI wont do home delivery.They will make local distributor contact you.

expect a reply MAXIMUM 3-4 days from now.

he should reply by wednesday.
Ooops, I forgot to give him my phone number, anyway if he replies I will give him my phone number and have a distri contact me, first I'll go to chandni tomorrow to see if vedant/md can import it for me.

Do I need to send him my phone number? Or can I wait for his reply?
 

Skud

Super Moderator
Staff member
Here's a review of MSI GTX 580 Lightning Xtreme Edition 3gb. Looks freakin' awesome!!!

MSI GTX 580 Lightning Xtreme Edition (XE) 3GB Review
 
OP
tkin

tkin

Back to school!!
wait for reply.he will ask you for P/N in that lol.
I'm becoming hyper, if this goes through this will be the highest config I have ever bought and consist of the fastest components in their respective categories, this is like a dream come true for me, so I am so tensed up right now.
 
Top Bottom