F.E.A.R has lots of lame attempts at scaring players. But the gameplay is awesome. Its just that its a wannabe scary game. This wannabeness is lame. On the other hand, Doom 3 has good scary moments but its way to irritating to play without lights. I didnt have the patience to play so I never played the 4th level. The scariest games i played were all less than 3 mb - 5 days a stranger, 6 days a sacrifice, trilby's notes and 7 days a skeptic.