DELL Ultrasharp U2311 - IPS vs ASUS PA238Q - IPS. Which is better?

R

robotsmani

Journeyman
Hi,

I have short listed for these two IPS monitors. Please suggest which is good.

DELL Ultrasharp U2311(LCD, DVI, VGA) - 14k net
ASUS PA238Q(LED, DVI, HDMI, VGA) - 15.2k plus tax

Is it worth buying with HDMI and LED?

Planning to buy this saturday...please suggest.

Thanks,
Mani
 
G

gargdada

Right off the assembly line
robotsmani said:
Hi,

I have short listed for these two IPS monitors. Please suggest which is good.

DELL Ultrasharp U2311(LCD, DVI, VGA) - 14k net
ASUS PA238Q(LED, DVI, HDMI, VGA) - 15.2k plus tax

Is it worth buying with HDMI and LED?

Planning to buy this saturday...please suggest.

Thanks,
Mani
Click to expand...

ASUS PA238Q over DELL Ultrasharp U2311 anyday..
(just registered to this forum to reply you)
looking for the same myself and after 3 days of intensive search i can definitely say that PA23Q is farrrrrrrrr superior...

Plz let me knw where are you getting this price with vendors number if possible.. price i m getting is much higher than this. :) thx..
 
aniket.cain

aniket.cain

Padawan
gargdada said:
ASUS PA238Q over DELL Ultrasharp U2311 anyday..
(just registered to this forum to reply you)
looking for the same myself and after 3 days of intensive search i can definitely say that PA23Q is farrrrrrrrr superior...

Plz let me knw where are you getting this price with vendors number if possible.. price i m getting is much higher than this. :) thx..
Click to expand...

Could you please elaborate how the Asus one is 'farrrrrrrrr superior'?
 
OP
R

robotsmani

Journeyman
Here is some comparison

DELL --------- ASUS
LCD-----------LED
8-bit color------10-bit color
No-HDMI--------HDMI
No-PIP/PBP------PIP/PBP - Picture in picture/picture by picture
8ms (gray to gray)--6ms (Gray to Gray)
Contrast Ratio:
1000 to 1 (typical),
10,000:1 (dynamic)-------- Contrast Ratio (ASCR) : 50000000:1
14k net------------------15.2k + Tax

Price from aashirwad computers s p road bangalore

I was almost decided to buy DELL, Dinesh(aashirwaad computers) told me about the ASUS. Some 2k diff we can get the LED, HDMI and PIP. Otherwise both are similar. Also i found in the net, there are some defective DELL pieces around. So i am scared little in DELL. Tomorrow i am going to SP road. Let's see which one i will buy :neutral:
 
Last edited:
G

gargdada

Right off the assembly line
@aniket - i guess robotsmani's table has made my point abt faaarrrrrrrrrrr superior :) :) But the crown jewel is that PA238Q is factory calibrated. It is very tough to manually calibrate a monitor properly.

@robotsmani - try not to play with the brightness, contrast n color settings.. it would be a real pain to re calibrate them properly (if there is not reset to default option)

i m myself looking for the same monitor.. price quoted to me is 15.2k (final price).. but its not available for 10 days atleast. Tried asus sales in delhi and mumbai. its not available with any :-(
 
G

gamekraze

Broken In
Let me know if it has bad bleeding problems.. or is it hardly noticeable. Also is there any ghosting that you noticed?
 
OP
R

robotsmani

Journeyman
Ishu Gupta said:
Congrats. Just pics won't do. We want a full blown review. ;)
Click to expand...

Sure. I will do the review, but let me use it for one week :wink:

gargdada said:
@robotsmani - try not to play with the brightness, contrast n color settings.. it would be a real pain to re calibrate them properly (if there is not reset to default option)

i m myself looking for the same monitor.. price quoted to me is 15.2k (final price).. but its not available for 10 days atleast. Tried asus sales in delhi and mumbai. its not available with any :-(
Click to expand...

i just reduced contrast and brightness to 50 as it was 100 and it is straining my eyes.

In here bangalore i didn't get the monitor anywhere else and aashirwaad is having only one stock with him.

gamekraze said:
Let me know if it has bad bleeding problems.. or is it hardly noticeable. Also is there any ghosting that you noticed?
Click to expand...

No bleeding. No Ghosting. :-D
 
OP
R

robotsmani

Journeyman
Hi All,

Actually i want to do a complete review for this monitor. For that i want to use it for a month and play some games and see for the ghosting. i was waiting for my GPU and the Games.

BUT i getting PMs asking about the backlight bleeding issue. So i rushed to write this post to help people whose planning to buy this monitor.

This monitor is having backlight bleeding issue.

Using this monitor for first 2weeks i have not noticed any bleeding. After that i started seeing the bleeding happening corners(left bottom & right top).

Actually when i switch on the monitor, this bleeding is not noticeable. After two or three hours of usage it starts.

I asked the dealer about this. He has given the Rashi perpherals no. I have not talked to those people, because i am going on vacation next week. Also i am worrying that if they do RMA or not. if they do also i am not sure how long it will take. So i am thinking to start the RMA process after diwali.

What you people think?

Other than the bleeding everything else is great. i am still loving it :)


NOTE: Before buying this monitor please check it thoroughly
 
Last edited:
M

mrcool63

Journeyman
i was planning to buy this but it cant be found anywhere..

The shop people call it 'kohinoor ka heera':lol:
It disappears faster than it appears apparently.. very hard to find..
actually even the dell suffered from backlight bleed in the initial issues.. is it that bad in this?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom