Analyst Says Nokia's MeeGo is "the Biggest Joke In the Tech Industry Right Now"

Status
Not open for further replies.
OP
pauldmps

pauldmps

Banned
^^ Only N9 has been killed. It doesn't mean that the Meego has been terminated. However, the series of news that came yesterday makes it a speculation.

Now the question are :

If Nokia adopts WP7 now & later Meego gets ready, what will happen in such situation ?
Are they adopting WP7 temporarily or they're going after multi-os strategy like HTC ?
 

desiibond

Bond, Desi Bond!
^^ Only N9 has been killed. It doesn't mean that the Meego has been terminated. However, the series of news that came yesterday makes it a speculation.

Now the question are :

If Nokia adopts WP7 now & later Meego gets ready, what will happen in such situation ?
Are they adopting WP7 temporarily or they're going after multi-os strategy like HTC ?

Maybe,

Business series -> WP7
Tablets -> MeeGo
Mainstream phones -> Symbian s^3 and higher
lowend and budget phones -> S60/S40
 

lywyre

Cyborg Agent
^^ But what about WebOS. Nokia hardware is good enough for WebOS and Nokia's identity can remain intact. HP will only be the other maker of WebOS devices
 
OP
pauldmps

pauldmps

Banned
@ lywyre

It is not about OSes but about the whole ecosystem that Nokia is considering. Perhaps that's why they did not consider Android. Shipping handsets with Android will lead to users downloading apps from the Android market directly benefiting Google.

Same goes for HP. Also it is not known that if HP allows WebOS to be used on non-HP devices.

Adopting WP7 will also cause users to download from Windows Market but Nokia might share revenue with Microsoft or also sell apps through their OVI store. That is what we will find out tomorrow.

Things are turning out funnier day by day. First the turkey tweet & now this gizmodo article:

*betacache.gawkerassets.com/assets/images/4/2011/02/xlarge_nokiamesssy.jpg

Nokia’s Unfortunate Sauna Addiction

Brian Barrett — Okay, so maybe it's kind of funny that the BBC has called out Nokia for the struggling mobile company's crippling sauna addiction. That doesn't mean it's not a legitimate concern! Because when your company's this far down in the dumps, it might not be the right time to install a steam room in your Zimbabwe office.


Here's the thing: it's not just about saunas (although, again, pretty funny!). It's about corporate culture. The company that holds fast to its extreme perks even in the face of mounting losses is the same one that's going to hold fast to Symbian, the qualitative runt of the world's smartphone platforms. It's also the same one that needs a serious kick in the pants from its new CEO.

I appreciate—or at least, have just learned—that making a deal over a good steam how things happen in Finland. I even understand why Nokia might want to install the luxury in offices as far flung as Afghanistan. I'd just appreciate it more if the company were doing that while also managing to be wildly successful. There's a fine line between "eccentric billionaire" and "lunatic."

The point is that Stephen Elop has got a much bigger challenge ahead of him than fixing the bottom line. He's got to implement change on a scale, starting with how Nokia executives relate with each other—and the rest of the business world. It's not unlike what Howard Stringer has faced, with mixed success, at Sony these past five years.

If I were him, I'd be sweating bullets.
 
Last edited:

NIGHTMARE

ANGEL OF DEATH
Intel kept in the dark over Nokia’s MeeGo plans; operators reject first device

Intel kept in the dark over Nokia’s MeeGo plans; operators reject first device.

Prior to the public announcement on Friday, Intel was kept in the dark with regards to Nokia’s plans to relegate MeeGo to a glorified R&D project, sources with knowledge of the situation tell TechCrunch Europe.

The U.S. chip maker, it appears, was caught off guard as were many media outlets and analysts – this publication aside – with the news that Nokia has forged a long term partnership with Microsoft that will see the handset maker adopt Windows Phone as its primary smartphone platform. Intel, which along with Nokia is developing the MeeGo operating system, is said to be extremely concerned now that Nokia will inevitably reduce its engineering commitment, which it desperately needs, and where this leaves plans to get its Atom chip into smartphones and other mobile devices.

We’ve also learned that Nokia’s first MeeGo device, originally scheduled to be announced late last year, has been sent back to the drawing board by operators.

The problem, says our source, is in relation to the “flimsy” hardware keyboard mechanism, which fell short of operator standards. This is surprising as it’s thought to share a similar hinge to the N97 and E7, both of which were accepted by carriers, although it could be that MeeGo requires a larger CPU and battery compared to Symbian and therefore leaves less room in the chassis. As a result, the first MeeGo smartphone, thought to be the N9-00, has indeed been canned. Instead, a second (and possibly last) MeeGo smartphone on the roadmap – the N9-01 – sans physical keyboard will be pushed out first, as earlier reported by Engadget.

Interestingly, well-placed sources also tell us that the device won’t feature the stock MeeGo UI but instead one designed by “a three person external team rather than any of Nokia’s hundreds of internal designers.” It could be announced as early as tomorrow at Mobile World Congress.

While not creating quite the same fanfare as Nokia’s newly forged partnership with Microsoft, the tie-in with Intel to co-develop MeeGo announced just under a year ago was seen by the industry as a pretty big deal. It was hoped that the open-source OS would put Nokia back into a leadership position in the smartphone space as Symbian inevitably trickled down to lower-cost, mass-market devices, while in turn and somewhat ironically it would give Intel the heavyweight partner it needed to “catalyse” MeeGo’s ecosystem. It also added immediate credibility to the chip maker’s aim to put “Intel inside” smartphones, tablets and other types of converged devices.

Twelve months later, however, and it’s abundantly clear that Nokia is choosing to “catalyse” Microsoft’s Windows Phone ecosystem instead.

Source
 
OP
pauldmps

pauldmps

Banned
Here's another news from Gizmodo:

Source: Gizmodo, the Gadget Guide

*betacache.gawkerassets.com/assets/images/4/2011/02/xlarge_stephenelopnokiaceo.jpg

Why Didn’t Nokia Use Android? Because That Would Be Giving Up
By now, you know that Nokia decided to side with Microsoft and Windows Phone 7 instead of Google and Android. Why didn't they want Android? Because Nokia felt that that would be going down without a fight.


Nokia considered three OSes to move to: MeeGo, Android or Windows Phone 7. In talking about Android, Elop admits to its strength but also points out some weaknesses:

"There's something happening there. There's no denying that. [But] our sense was differentiation could be a pretty big challenge. The risk for commoditization would increase dramatically."

Nokia knew that it was too late to join the Android party—Android had become a crowded space. Creating a standout Android phone would not only be difficult given the experience of other companies but because it could get lost in the maul of Android phones available. Even Android phone makers would admit that it's hard to stay at the top of the Android power rankings—hell, doesn't it seem like the "best Android phone" only has a lifespan of a month before it gets dethroned? Nokia saw Google eventually getting all the profits as hardware gets commoditized.

And maybe Windows Phone 7 will have those same hardware "issues" as Android but Nokia felt it could differentiate its handsets by dropping in Nokia specific features like their Navteq location-based services. That, they felt, would give them a leg up.

But none of those arguments seem to matter as much as this one: Nokia didn't want to lose the smartphone wars without giving Google and Apple an honest fight. Choosing Android would mean that they'd become a bit player in a two-horse race (Apple vs Google). Choosing Windows Phone means they're hoping and fighting to add another horse. It might be too late and maybe Nokia had to sell their soul, who knows, but I respect any one who goes down swinging. [AllThingsD]
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom