@infra_red_dude, I know that you know a lot more about mobile phones than I do. I acknowledge and respect that. But I'm not a total goner either.
So take my reply in the right spirit, like you always do.
infra_red_dude said:
The worst excuse I've ever seen! I mean... haha... Ok No comments!
First, the trailer:
Look at this thread. Read the second post. Turning 3G off on the N95 saves a lot of battery.
Then, read this article on AnandTech:
No 3G on the iPhone, but why? A Battery Life Analysis
These are Anand Lal Shimpi's final words:
Without a doubt, current 3G implementations do require more space and consume more power than simply outfitting a phone with support for EDGE. Using the Samsung Blackjack as an example, turning on 3G reduces battery life by around 25% under web/email use. The biggest impact of all is, surprisingly enough, talk time; with 3G enabled, the Blackjack's talk time is cut in half, with absolutely no benefit realized from the higher bandwidth standard.
At the same time, Apple's choice to include 802.11b/g support in the iPhone makes a lot of sense. Battery life actually increases with Wi-Fi over EDGE whenever the data connection is being used, not to mention that performance goes up tremendously as well.
Apple had to make a number of tradeoffs with the iPhone, and without a doubt its power hungry screen was not worth sacrificing, even for better network performance. The iPhone's biggest selling point is its UI, and Apple seems to have made the right tradeoff by embracing Wi-Fi for the first generation - as frustrating as it may be for users.
The long term solution however isn't simply to rely on Wi-Fi hotspots for faster net access, as 3G deployments become even more widespread and technology improves you can expect to see lower power and more tightly integrated 3G chipsets available. We'd venture a guess that a 3G iPhone is at least 12 months out, but until then keep an eye out for 802.11 hotspots - you'll get a better usage experience and better battery life on your iPhone.
[Emphasis added.]
infra_red_dude said:
While the comparison is perfectly alright, 3G in US is not as you put in. 3G was first intro'd in US in 2003 (or 2002?). This year if the sales of the handsets are anything to go by then that will give an idea about 3G in US.
I have read on many blogs and forums that USA does not have a robust 3G network.
infra_red_dude said:
Actually to conserve battery life they couldn've excluded the camera, wifi etc. All these hog battery more than "3G"!
I wish that Apple had chosen to do away with the camera but it is a huge selling point. Phones without cameras just don't sell so I guess Apple did not have any choice. As for Wi-Fi, well, it consumes less battery than 3G does and it is a much better option IMHO. You can have Wi-Fi anywhere. You don't need to depend on the network or carrier. I would prefer it to 3G any day.
infra_red_dude said:
They don't need to "figure" out. They just need to release the models that were/are 3G ready
Alas, I think you are wrong. They need to figure out how to include it in that thin a device while having a good battery life. To quote Anand Lal Shimpi,
"as 3G deployments become even more widespread and technology improves you can expect to see lower power and more tightly integrated 3G chipsets available." I think they are waiting for that time. This is what I meant when I said that they need to figure it out.
infra_red_dude said:
I fully agree with you regarding this. Every bit!
I fully agree with myself regarding this too. Every bit!
infra_red_dude said:
My cuz recently bought an iPod Touch and I must say that the exprience of using it in itself is an amazing one. As the Mac Guys say, the iPhone has nothing "new" but the way we "do" things on it is different. And I agree to each word of theirs
And it is exactly the same feeling with Mac OS X. It does not do better things, it does things in better ways.
desiibond said:
3G iphone is just a marketing tactic. Put 3G and increase the price further. Increase the profits.
First release phone without 3G. Then put 3G on it and increase the price.
I can bet you anything the price of iPhone v2.0 will either be the same as it is now or it will be decreased. There is no chance of the price getting hiked. Apple never increases the prices when it upgrades its products, be it Macs or iPods, and now the iPhone. Standard Apple policy.
gx_saurav said:
Right, what about all other phones which support 3G fine?
They either make other tradeoffs or have a crappy battery life.
gx_saurav said:
U R wrong, in USA 3G Is there more then Europe.
LOL!
Are you never tired of being so blatantly wrong!
gx_saurav said:
Starbucks isn't available in India yet
All you need to do to have a Wi-Fi connection is buy a Rs. 2,000 Wi-Fi router. You don't need Starbucks for the Wi-Fi!