Want to try new Ryzen for light video editing & grading

V

vivek g delhi

Broken In
gurujee said:
I really appreciate the help and guidance from the forum and thanks very much Vivek for the much needed config options.

How much more performance i can gain if i choose i7 8700 over i5 8400?

do you recommend a gfx card to the intel config for adding filters/ or working with lumetri presets & luts in premier ? if yes, which one?

I am being tempted for 2nd config as well as the total cost with the LG 4k monitor will be around 110000 which will allow me to add a gfx card if needed.
Click to expand...
Sorry I cant help with this. Rule of thumb is the more the better. Again some discussion about Lumetri is present in LIVE PLABACK section at:

Premiere Pro CC 2017.1.2 CPU Performance: Core i7 8700K, i5 8600K, i3 8350K

Check out the RAW results

Its written
The Core i5 8600K also did fairly and only fell behind a bit with 4K RED footage that included Lumetri Color Correction and cross dissolves. Even then, the fact that it can play that kind of project at half resolution without dropping any frames is pretty good.

I7-8700k is 31% better than i7-7700k while i5-8600k is 8-17% better. So roughly 20% diff between the two. Will a GPU add 30% to i5?


I cannot get any comparative info on whether i5 to i7 is better move than i5+GPU.


Sent from my SM-G920I using Tapatalk
 
V

vivek g delhi

Broken In
vivek g delhi said:
Sorry I cant help with this. Rule of thumb is the more the better. Again some discussion about Lumetri is present in LIVE PLABACK section at:

Premiere Pro CC 2017.1.2 CPU Performance: Core i7 8700K, i5 8600K, i3 8350K

Check out the RAW results

Its written
The Core i5 8600K also did fairly and only fell behind a bit with 4K RED footage that included Lumetri Color Correction and cross dissolves. Even then, the fact that it can play that kind of project at half resolution without dropping any frames is pretty good.

I7-8700k is 31% better than i7-7700k while i5-8600k is 8-17% better. So roughly 20% diff between the two. Will a GPU add 30% to i5?


I cannot get any comparative info on whether i5 to i7 is better move than i5+GPU.


Sent from my SM-G920I using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Some more digging around Studio1productions website.

GPU will accelerate Lumetri , deinterlacing, blending, scaling, rendering previews, effects and acceleated playback. You need minimum 640 CUDA cores (GTX 1050) 128bit 2GB card for FHD and 1000 CUDA cores 4GB/6GB better and a 256 bit card for 4K. GTX 1070 is 256 bit while 1060 is 192 bit but i guess you will need to take a call on pricing. People are really happy with 1060 as well.
Attached are configs with 27inch 4k and 1050TI. Add 14000 to pricing for 1060 6GB. Also the official accelerated effects in the snapshot.*uploads.tapatalk-cdn.com/20171011/1463e2c835cf21f865b3a8cfbd7231e0.jpg*uploads.tapatalk-cdn.com/20171011/efd3cc45220b5184e469a1877f304239.jpg*uploads.tapatalk-cdn.com/20171011/88bbc33c578d84154c41fadbf2f91e1c.jpg

Sent from my SM-G920I using Tapatalk
 
OP
gurujee

gurujee

Can't Talk. In The Zone.
Should I go with BenQ PD2700Q instead of LG 27UD68-P

Difference is Benq is 2k but gives true 10bit colour over LG's 10-bit (8-bit + A-FRC)

further, LG one is being marketed primarily as a gaming monitor unlike BenQ which is targeted primarily towards content creators.
Am I wrong somewhere?
 
V

vivek g delhi

Broken In
gurujee said:
Should I go with BenQ PD2700Q instead of LG 27UD68-P

Difference is Benq is 2k but gives true 10bit colour over LG's 10-bit (8-bit + A-FRC)

further, LG one is being marketed primarily as a gaming monitor unlike BenQ which is targeted primarily towards content creators.
Am I wrong somewhere?
Click to expand...
I have the LG and it's quite good. Irs git swivel and tilt. Its factory caliberated and the gaming chops are its support for AMDsync something tech. Otherwise being IPS, the input lag is not suitable for gaming and TN panels are better.
For 10 bit color, jusy check that most likely you need Quadro graphics. Thats nVidia s way of selling Pro cards to professionals. Did you get any comparative reviews?

Sent from my SM-G920I using Tapatalk
 
OP
gurujee

gurujee

Can't Talk. In The Zone.
oh my bad... yes not aware of the quadro.

some says 4k is good for 32+ screens. for 27 qhd is better. ?

vivek g delhi said:
I have the LG and it's quite good. Irs git swivel and tilt. Its factory caliberated and the gaming chops are its support for AMDsync something tech. Otherwise being IPS, the input lag is not suitable for gaming and TN panels are better.
For 10 bit color, jusy check that most likely you need Quadro graphics. Thats nVidia s way of selling Pro cards to professionals. Did you get any comparative reviews?

Sent from my SM-G920I using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
 
V

vivek g delhi

Broken In
gurujee said:
oh my bad... yes not aware of the quadro.

some says 4k is good for 32+ screens. for 27 qhd is better. ?
Click to expand...
Non sense. What's the harm in text appearing sharper. You always need to use scaling with 4k. I often connect my laotop to my 55incher 4k tv. Without scaling text is small even at 55 inches. The only issue is that many apps are nit DPI aware, Nikons ViewNX-i being one and they scale really badly. I am sure Premiere and other professional video editors of all apps would be DPI aware

Sent from my SM-G920I using Tapatalk
 
V

vivek g delhi

Broken In
gurujee said:
oh my bad... yes not aware of the quadro.

some says 4k is good for 32+ screens. for 27 qhd is better. ?
Click to expand...
QHD may be good enough but future is 4k. Already 8k cine cameras have hit the market. The new 850 is 46MP which is beyond 8k. 100 MP medium formats are out there. People are experimenting with multiple fused camers. You can never have enough resolution I say!

Sent from my SM-G920I using Tapatalk
 
OP
gurujee

gurujee

Can't Talk. In The Zone.
Thanks ... really cleared my mind. 4k all the way.

vivek g delhi said:
QHD may be good enough but future is 4k. Already 8k cine cameras have hit the market. The new 850 is 46MP which is beyond 8k. 100 MP medium formats are out there. People are experimenting with multiple fused camers. You can never have enough resolution I say!

Sent from my SM-G920I using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom