Dell Studio 15 or HP 1221 TX

[varunparakh]

I want to buy a notebook mainly for gaming.Suggest me which one is better for playing the latest demanding games like crysis,gta 4 etc..

Chioice 1ell Studio 15

Processor
Intel® Centrino® 2 Mobile Technology Intel® CoreTM 2 Duo Processor P8600
Operating System
Genuine Windows Vista® Home Premium
Operating System
Chipset
Intel® Cantiga GM45 Chipset
Memory
4GB Dual-channel DDR2 SDRAM (2 x 2GB)
Hard Drive
320GB 7600RPM SATA Hard Drive
Display/Monitor
15.6” 720p WLED (1366x768) TrueLifeTM
Graphic Card
512MB ATI Mobility Radeon HD 4570
CD-ROM/DVD-ROM/Disk drive
Slot Load 8X max DVD+/-RW D with DVD+R double layer write capability
I/O Ports
VGA, HDMI 3x USB 2.0 (1x USB/E-SATA combo, 2x standard) IEEE 1394a / Gigabit NIC (no RJ11 – via dongle for USB External Modem) 1x Stereo in, 2x headphone/speaker out 8 in 1 media card reader ExpressCard 34

Approx 55K

Choice 2:HP DV5 1221TX

Processor
Intel C2D T6400(2GHz,@MB L2 Cache,800 MHz FSB)
15'4" Infinity Flush Glass WideScreen
HDMI v1.3 with HDCP Key
Hybrid TV Tuner Card
4GB PC-26400 DDR2(800MHz)
320 GB Serial ATA (5400RPM)
nVIDIA GeForce 9600 M GT(512MB)
FingerPrint Reader,Integrated Web Camera & Microphones
Blu-ray Drive with SuperMulti DL(8.5GB)DVD Writer
Windows Vista Home Premium(32bit
Three USB 2.0 Ports, • One IEEE 1394a Port (4 pins), Two Stereo Headphone Jacks, One RJ-11, One RJ-45, One VGA Out, Expansion port 3 - Docking port


Costing Approx 59K

 

[dOm1naTOr]

The first one seem better in proccy, HDD and other stuffs except GPU.
BTW dun expect much from a 9600M GT DDR2. Its no better than an 8600GT DDR3.
9600M GT has only 32 SP unlike the desktop version with 96 SP.

 

[desiibond]

^^btw, both the GPUs are almost equal (HD4570 and 9600M)

 

[varunparakh]

So overall for gaming performance,which one should i prefer.
I can also wait for some time,there is a chance that i would buy it in July!!
So any upcoming models to look for?

 

[damngoodman999]

P8600 & T6400 donot make much difference ,, 9600GT is much better than 4570 but id DDR2 means it waste ,,

but HP 1221 TX has battery problem , only 1/2 hr back up , with GPU card laptop get 9 cell battery for atleast 3 hrs of backup .

 

[dOm1naTOr]

, 9600GT is much better than 4570 but id DDR2 means it waste ,,

u are loosing the point The 9600M GT does not even deserve to be called a 9600 series with its puny 32 SP.
it more or less equals an 8600GT[32SP, 540 core ddr3], but maybe even lower due to DDR2 and lower 500Mhz core clock.

 

[damngoodman999]

^^ i said the same ,, yaar

 

[k4ce]

get the dell bro ... more reliable ....

 

[varunparakh]

*www.notebookcheck.net/Computer-Games-on-Laptop-Graphic-Cards.13849.0.html

dis confuses me even more...Maan what to get??
Help

 

[k4ce]

*www.notebookcheck.net/Mobile-Graphics-Cards-Benchmark-List.844.0.html .... this page gives u a better idea ... 4570 is ranked 64 but the 9600 is ranked 51 ... so u decide ... but its not jus the graphic card , its even the processor .... and the dell's got better ....