OP
Zangetsu
I am the master of my Fate.
Can PM reverse the order passed by Supreme Court ?
Distribute soft-drink among lawyers or face disciplinary action
- Thread starter Zangetsu
- Start date
RumbaMon19
Feel Pain.
From what my teacher told me in school, judiciary, executive and legislature are three things with equal powers so as to maintain each other. Now that is about 9-10 year old thing taught to me in 8th class civics, so maybe changed now.
But for sure PM cannot alone reverse the order of SC.
But for sure PM cannot alone reverse the order of SC.
vidhubhushan
Alakh Niranjan
legally, PM alone can not do so but the Parliament i.e. both houses can pass a legislation / amendment to change / modify / reverse any Supreme Court Judgment.
Supreme Court can also change / modify / junk some legislation / amendment.
Why some orders / judgments kept in reserve condition by both HC and SC ? If a order is passed then why not announce it then and there. Instead sometime courts just reserve the order, why is that ?
vidhubhushan
Alakh Niranjan
many times the court wants to make sure everything is written is proper detail so that there is no loophole in the judgment. in this situation the best option is to reserve judgment and deliver it when it is checked properly that everything is covered.
most of the time through newspaper / tv news, what general public gets to know is a line or few lines only when the actual judgment may be of multiple pages which might have quotes of advocates on either side, part of some law and / or part of some previous judgment. to get it prepared properly, court requires time.
vidhubhushan
Alakh Niranjan
it is not wise to compare a district court lawyer with a high court lawyer or a supreme court lawyer. the knowledge part is different. yes you may find many lawyers at the same place who don't know anything about law and practice; we see many such people everyday and deal with them. when a matter reaches supreme court, the top most court, then it means either it has passed all courts below and then has reached there or it can / should not be taken up in any court below. in such a situation, someone who can analyse the matter and present a case on the basis of different previous various judgments and explanations - someone who has more experience and better grasp of matter. this specialist will ask a higher fee, something similar to a superspecialist doctor. some less experienced people are also there but then they learn the know how of working and drafting the petitions in the supreme court.