23 - 24" IPS Monitors.

summers

Journeyman
Hi all,

I want to purchase an IPS Monitor for general purpose work / movies and some casual gaming. Earlier i had decided to buy AOC i 2353 PH, but one of my friend suggested not to go for it as it is not having DVI connectivity.

So, I've zeroed on three monitors :

Dell Ultrasharp U2312hm / U2412.
Asus PA238Q IPS.

Now, the thing is that Asus PA238Q is having better reviews than both of the Dell models.

Asus is offering 3 year warranty whereas Dell is offering 3 year premium panel Guarantee on their models. The Asus have a bad reputation regarding their after sales service whereas Dell is quite excellent in this aspect.

I also want advice from our forum friends who have used Ultrasharp monitors regarding their experience.

I m really confused and any help in this regard will be highly appreciated.:-(
 

yochan

Broken In
Dude dell u 2312 hm costs about 13800 n asus pa238q costs 19200

Asus prices habe gone up ever since people started buying it

Asus is good out of the box,dell has to be adjusted
both use the same lg pannel with agressive anti glare which is quite annoying

The only difference between asus n dell is that asus uses a new processor or chip what ever u call it ...both look the same feel the same except for hdmi n pip
 

Darth Vader

In the zone
I've been using Dell Ultrasharp U2312HM past 3 weeks. It's an excellent monitor for watching HD movies, Gaming & Graphics works.

There is a slight Backlight Bleeding on Top left and Bottom right corner of my monitor, which i heard is too high & noticeable on Asus PA238Q monitors.

You can find a lot of calibrated ICC profile for Dell Ultrasharp though Asus is pre-calibrated from the factory and has HDMI port.

Overall I'm more than happy with Dell Ultrasharp U2312HM :)

CHeck the below review:
ASUS PA238Q 23 vs Dell UltraSharp U2312HM 23" | Digital Storm Forums
esp the post 11 by dspillett
 
OP
summers

summers

Journeyman
I contacted Dell directly and they gave me a quote of Rs. 15,023 for U2312HM and Rs. 20,570 for Dell U2412M. Since, i stay in West Bengal, so they will be shipping it through Speed Post.

I think i would go with Dell 2313HM.
 

thydigit

Broken In
Hi,
I am looking for monitor for design purpose. Is above mentioned dell models will fit or any other suggestions? Also if possible please post online purchase link. Thanks in advance:)
 

ashintomson

Journeyman
am using asus pro art i wont find any problems in my monitor bleeding is not that noticeable .. :) dell is also good ... its ur call ...
 
OP
summers

summers

Journeyman
Finally bought DEll U2312HM for Rs. 15200/- from a Dell reseller. The Monitor is great, though a bit of backlight bleeding is observed at lower left corner.
I am highly satisfied. Thanks all for your suggestions.
 

Revolution

Wise Old Owl
Is Dell U2312HM good for gaming ?
Heard it got 8ms input lag G2G.
Dell is overprice compared to AOC,LG and other too.
Is LG IPS236V available in India ?
 
OP
summers

summers

Journeyman
Is Dell U2312HM good for gaming ?
Heard it got 8ms input lag G2G.
Dell is overprice compared to AOC,LG and other too.
Is LG IPS236V available in India ?

Yes its good for gaming..you won't notice any sort of ghosting. The 8ms input lag quoted is actual as compared to other brands which quote 2-5ms lag when there actual lag ranges from 5-10ms. Dell is overpriced coz its an IPS panel (and hence 8ms input lag) compared to its peers who offer TN panel. Google for reviews on Dell U2312HM to get an overall picture.

Dell UltraSharp U2312HM, 23” Monitor Review

LG IPS236V is not available in India as of now.U can also go for AOC i2353PH if you want quality for a cheaper price, but u might experience ghosting on some ocassions.
 
OP
summers

summers

Journeyman
I also want dell u2312. I am from Mumbai.
Please give me some advice getting one in cost effective way. :p

You may contact Dell directly and get a quote from them...or find a Dell reseller in your City.

My advice, take the prices from both of them and go with the cheaper quote.

Dell guys have excellent packaging & shipping.
 
Top Bottom